Rawlings Gold Glove Award Selection Criteria Overview
Players who want to be considered for a given position must have played a certain number of games or innings (depending on the position) at that position.
- All pitchers must have pitched in at least 141 innings by the time their club plays in its 141st game. In order to be eligible for the 141st game (a minimum of 71 games), a catcher must have appeared in at least half of his team’s games. By his team’s 141st game, all infielders and outfielders must have played in the field for at least 713 total innings, which equates to an average of approximately 7.5 innings per game in approximately 67 percent of his team’s games
- This ensures that only full-time players are taken into consideration
- And Those infielders and outfielders who have accumulated at least 713 total innings played qualify for the position at which he played the most innings (i.e., where his manager employed him the most).
- There are no specific fielding measurements or statistics that determine who wins the Rawlings Gold Glove Award®
- Rather, it is a recognition of overall fielding performance that does not take into account offensive productivity. Only the manager and six (6) coaches for each Major League Baseball team vote, for a total of seven (7) ballots per team. Each individual must sign the entire Ballot in order to be declared legitimate
- Managers and coaches are unable to vote for their own players and are only able to vote for players from their own League. In the case of qualified LF instead of three general OF, managers and coaches cast ballots for specific players at specific positions rather than in broad terms. Eligibility for a Rawlings Gold Glove Award closely matches qualification rules set out in MLB Rule 10.22 (Minimum Standards for Individual Championships) (Minimum Standards for Individual Championships). Only players who are mentioned in the resource guide are eligible for a Rawlings Gold Glove Award in the exact position that is specified in the resource guide for that position. Please refer to the “NotesGlossary” section of the resource guide for information on player qualification for certain positions. The votes are kept private between Major League Baseball and Rawlings Sporting Goods Company, Inc.
- The qualified players are arranged alphabetically
SABR Defensive Index
The SABR Defensive IndexTM (SDI) is a measure of the amount of runs saved by a player’s defensive performance over the course of a season, compared to the typical defensive player at that position. In order to calculate the SDI, six (6) separate defensive data sources are used to combine measurements. These include parameters that score the defender’s arm strength and accuracy, range, and sure-handedness, as well as the frequency of “good” and “bad” fielding plays that he makes, among others.
The following are provided for catchers: blocking balls in the dirt and stolen bases/caught stealing.
A positive SDI implies that a player performed above average when compared to other players in his position during the season in question.
The Rawlings Gold Glove Awards are determined by a combination of manager/coach evaluations and SABR ratings.
Gold Glove Award
A Gold Glove Award is given annually to the Major League player who has the “superior individual fielding performance” at each position (in each league), as determined by the managers and coaches in each league. In Americanbaseball, the award is known as the Rawlings Gold Glove Award, or simply the Gold Glove. Each year, eighteen Gold Gloves are given to players in both the National League and the American League, one for each of the nine positions on the field. Please keep in mind that the phrase “at each of nine spots” is not entirely correct.
- A number of critics have long advocated for the awarding of a single Gold Glove for each particular outfield position, claiming that the three outfield positions are not easily interchangeable defensively as they are now.
- The Gold Glove was created by attaching a glove made of goldlamé-tanned leather to a walnut foundation, which was the first of its kind.
- Darin Erstad is the first player in history to earn Gold Gloves as both an infielder and an outfielder.
- Gold Glove awards are also given out in other baseball leagues, such as the Japanese Baseball League.
HammerichBradsby, the makers of Louisville Slugger bats, sponsored the Silver Slugger Classic in 1980 as part of its sponsorship of Major League Baseball. Award given to the player who hits the ball the hardest at each position.
American League winners
- Pitcher, catcher, first base, second base, shortstop, third base, and outfield (3) are all positions.
National League winners
- Pitcher, catcher, first and second base, shortstop, third base, outfield (3), pitcher, catcher, first and second base
Regarding Rawlings Rawlings Athletic Products Company, Inc. is a leading manufacturer and marketer of sporting goods in the United States and across the world. Rawlings is a genuine worldwide sports brand that has been trusted by generations of sportsmen of all abilities since its founding in 1887. Because of Rawlings’ unrivaled quality and superior craftsmanship, professional players, national governing bodies, and sports leagues continue to pick Rawlings above the competition. Official ball supplier and batting helmet of Major League Baseball®, official baseball of Minor League BaseballTM and the NCAA®, and a National High School Federation®-approved ball supplier for sports such as baseball, basketball, football, and softball.
In order to obtain further information, please visit Rawlings.comor call (314) 819-2800.
The Amateur Baseball Coaches Association (ABCA), which was established in 1945, is the premier professional association for baseball coaches at the amateur level.
Since its first meeting in June 1945 with 27 college baseball coaches, the National Collegiate Baseball Coaches Association has grown to encompass eight divisions: NCAA Division I, II, and III, NAIA, NJCAA, Pacific Association Division, High School Division, and Youth.
Your 2021 Gold Glove Award winners are .
Once again, it’s that time of year: award season! Aside from that, the Rawlings Gold Glove Awards, which are presented each offseason to the best defensive players at each position in each league, are among the most prestigious honors given out each year. The nominees for each position were released on October 28th, and the winners were announced on Sunday night on the ESPN television network. The Gold Glove Awards are being handed out in record numbers this year, with a single club taking home five awards in the same season for the first time in the awards’ history.
- Goldschmidt earns a fourth Gold Glove Award to his trophy case, marking the first time he has received one since 2017.
- Freddie Freeman of the Atlanta Braves and Max Muncy of the Los Angeles Dodgers were named runners-up.
- Despite the fact that his Astros were eliminated from the World Series – and that’s a big “other than” – Gurriel had a fantastic season all around.
- Matt Olson of the A’s and Jared Walsh of the Angels were named runners-up.
- Edman wins his first Gold Glove Award of his professional career in 2021 after leading all MLB second basemen in Outs Above Average (OAA) in that season.
- Ozzie Albies of the Braves and Kolten Wong of the Brewers were named runners-up.
- But let’s not forget his defensive contributions – he led all second basemen with 8.5 defensive runs above average, per FanGraphs.
Arenado’s eight defensive runs above average led NL third basemen, and his 10 Outs Above Average have him tied with McMahon for second in the league among third basemen.
He led all Major League third basemen with 17 Outs Above Average and 11 defensive runs above average.
The NL MVP Award candidate adds a fourth Gold Glove Award to his trophy shelf, and it’s his first since 2017.
In fact, no one in the Majors at any position had more – only the Pirates’ Stallings equaled him.
It’s also quite possibly the first of several to come.
Crawford, Mariners; Andrelton Simmons, Twins NL:Tyler O’Neill, Cardinals Make it two straight Gold Glove Awards for O’Neill, whose bat got the headlines during a breakout campaign at the plate, but whose glove was also a big reason the Cardinals reached the postseason.
Runners up: David Peralta of the Arizona Diamondbacks and AJ Pollock of the Los Angeles Dodgers.
He previously won the award in his first season with the Red Sox.
finished tied for second place with seven defensive runs saved, but he played left field for a significantly longer period of time in 2021 than either of the runners-up – he played 1,116 innings in left field, while Arozarena played 612 1/3 and Gurriel played 943 2/3.
of the Blue Jays were named runners-up.
As a result of Bader’s first career Gold Glove Award, he joins Benintendi and Kansas City’s Michael A.
Bader was the most productive center fielder in the National League, saving 15 runs and recording 14 Outs Above Average.
were the runners-up.
Taylor is a member of the AL.
This season, Taylor was first among all MLB center fielders in defensive runs saved (19) and outs above average (15), and he also tallied up 11 assists to earn his first Gold Glove award of his career.
Adam Duvall of the Marlins/Braves is the National League’s top pitcher.
However, his defense was outstanding as well – he topped all National League right fielders with nine defensive runs saved and was the most productive of the three contenders for this award with seven assists (he had 12 outfield assists overall).
AL:Joey Gallo, Texas Rangers/New York Yankees After putting together a strong defensive performance in right field during a season that saw him moved from Texas to New York, Gallo earns his second consecutive Gold Glove Award in the position.
Hunter Renfroe of the Red Sox and Kyle Tucker of the Astros were named runner-ups.
Stallings earns his first Gold Glove Award in his debut season with the Pittsburgh Pirates, in which he appeared in more than 61 games behind the plate.
Yadier Molina of the Cardinals and J.T.
Sean Murphy is the A’s quarterback.
With 10 defensive runs saved last season, the 27-year-old Oakland backstop was second in the American League, behind only Austin Hedges’ 12.
The Astros’ Martn Maldonado and the Royals’ Salvador Perez were named runners-up.
Fried threw six shutout innings to help the Braves win the World Series and was presented with a second Gold Glove Award.
Zach Davies of the Cubs and Zack Wheeler of the Phillies were named runner-ups.
Runners-up: José Berroa of the Twins and Zack Greinke of the Astros.
Most Gold Glove Awards at each position
The Rawlings Gold Glove Award has a long and illustrious history, which may be found here. It’s an incredible accomplishment to even be nominated for one of these awards throughout the course of a Major League career, but there are some players in baseball history who rank among the best in the game when it comes to outstanding defense. Here’s a look at the players who have earned the most Gold Glove Awards at each position, as well as the players who are actively leading their respective teams: Greg Maddux is the starting pitcher (18) Maddux was so dominant on the mound that it’s easy to forget that he also happened to be the guy with the most Gold Glove Awards of any player at any position in the history of baseball.
- If winning four consecutive National League Cy Young Awards from 1992 to 1995 wasn’t enough, if Maddux was still throwing, you had virtually no chance of winning a Gold Glove award as a National League pitcher during that time period.
- He made his Major League debut for the Rangers on June 20, 1991, against the White Sox and another Hall of Fame “Pudge,” Carlton Fisk, in a game against the White Sox.
- However, despite the fact that Rodriguez only appeared in 88 games during his rookie season, he went on to earn his first Gold Glove Award the following year.
- His tenth, which came in 2001, matched him with Johnny Bench for the most by a catcher in major league history.
- Yadier Molina is currently on the field (9) Keith Hernandez starts at first base (11) He was a five-time All-Star and a two-time World Series champion, and he was named the National League’s Co-Most Valuable Player of the Year in 1979.
- In eight of his 17 seasons as a major leaguer, Hernandez received MVP votes, including a runner-up finish in 1984 and a fourth-place finish in 1986.
- Paul Goldschmidt, Eric Hosmer, and Anthony Rizzo are all in the lineup (4) Roberto Alomar is the second baseman (10) Alomar won 10 Gold Glove Awards in 11 seasons with the Blue Jays, Orioles, and Indians between 1991 and 2001.
- As a defensive infielder, the Hall of Famer was a magician, and it was especially enjoyable to see him work with another famous defensive infielder – Omar Vizquel – up the middle for Cleveland.
- Brooks Robinson is the third baseman (16) To this day, Robinson is regarded as the finest defensive third baseman in baseball history, and with good reason.
- If you were an American League third baseman between 1960 and 1975 and your name wasn’t Brooks Robinson, you didn’t win the Gold Glove Award for the hot corner position during that time period.
Among his most memorable plays is the one he made on a ground ball down the third-base line by Cincinnati’s Lee May in Game 1 of the World Series at Riverfront Stadium – Robinson snatched the ball on the backhand as his momentum carried him well into foul territory and still managed to throw May out.
Nolan Arenado is currently active (9) Shortstop: Ozzie Smith (13), also known as “The Wizard.” For a baseball fan, those two words bring up visions of impossible defensive plays being completed, amazingly athletic double plays, and the traditional backflip when walking out to his position at shortstop for the St.
- In his 19-year career at shortstop, Smith was a walking highlight reel, earning the National League Gold Glove Award at the position every year from 1980 to 1992.
- “Go crazy, guys!” cries out Jack Buck, who made the memorable call of the moment.
- Barry Bonds is in the left field (8) The fact that Bonds is the all-time home run king means that he is yet another player whose defensive excellence is frequently eclipsed by his offensive achievements.
- Those characteristics enabled him to overcome, for the most part, the single aspect of his all-around game that was lacking – his arm strength – and succeed.
- Starling Marte and Tyler O’Neill are now on the field (2) Willie Mays plays in the center field (12) The “Say Hey Kid” is widely considered to be one of the finest all-around players in the history of baseball.
- Over the course of his 22-year Hall of Fame career, he won a total of 12 Gold Glove Awards, all of which came in a row from 1957 to 1968.
- At the Polo Grounds, it was an over-the-shoulder grab in deep center field, followed by a whirling throw, that kept a run from scoring on the play.
- Mays is the most decorated player in the history of the game.
- The same could be said for his outfield defense, as he won the National League Gold Glove Award in right field every year from 1961 to 1972.
- Clemente’s glove was, of course, only one component of his magnificent game; he also had exactly 3,000 hits, won the 1966 National League MVP Award, was a two-time World Series champion, and was named to the All-Star team in 12 of his 18 seasons in the Major League Baseball.
Mookie Betts and Jason Heyward are both in the lineup (5)
Minor League Baseball Names 2021 Rawlings Gold Glove Award® Winners
PUBLICATION NEW YORK, Nov. 12, 2021 (PRNewswire) – It was announced today that nine players would be honored with the Rawlings Gold Glove Award ® for defensive performance in the 2021 season by Minor League BaseballTM and Rawlings Sporting Goods Company, Inc. The news was revealed during the MLB Network presentation of the 2021 Defensive Player of the Year Awards, which aired today. The champions at each position were chosen from among players who competed in the 11 Minor Leagues for the whole season.
“We’d like to welcome the Rawlings Gold Glove Award® honorees for the Minor Leagues in 2021 to a distinguished group of defensive greats known as ‘The Finest in the Field,'” said Mike Thompson, Rawlings’ chief marketing officer.
“These nine players demonstrated outstanding defensive abilities in 2021, and we are pleased to recognize them with Rawlings Gold Glove Awards,” said Peter Woodfork, Senior Vice President, Minor League Operations and Development, Major League Baseball.
“On behalf of Major League Baseball, Minor League Baseball, and our wonderful partners at Rawlings, I’d like to congratulate each of the winners on their outstanding seasons.” “On behalf of Major League Baseball, Minor League Baseball, and our wonderful partners at Rawlings, I congratulate each of the winners on their outstanding seasons.” The following Minor League Baseball players have been selected to receive the Rawlings Gold Glove Award ® in 2021:
|Position||Player||Minor League Team(s)||Major League Organization|
|1B||Nick Pratto||Northwest Arkansas (AA), Omaha (AAA)||Kansas City|
|2B||Michael Massey||Quad Cities (High-A)||Kansas City|
|SS||Jose Tena||Lake County (High-A)||Cleveland|
|3B||Jared Triolo||Greensboro (High-A)||Pittsburgh|
|OF||Cristian Pache||Gwinnett (AAA)||Atlanta|
|OF||Brenton Doyle||Spokane (High-A)||Colorado|
|OF||Mike Harris II||Rome (High-A)||Atlanta|
|C||Adley Rutschman||Bowie (AA), Norfolk (AAA)||Baltimore|
|P||Drey Jameson||Hillsboro (High-A), Amarillo (AA)||Arizona|
First baseman for the Omaha Storm Chasers (Royals). Between Omaha (AAA) and Northwest Arkansas (AA), Nick Pratto recorded 879 total chances in 113 games, recording 813 putouts and 64 assists in the process. Hunter Beach High School in Huntington Beach, California, graduate Pratto, 23, was picked by the Kansas City Royals in the first round (14th overall) in the 2017 Major League Baseball Draft. Second baseman for the Quad Cities River Bandits (Royals). In 81 games, Michael Massey handled 284 total opportunities and assisted in the conversion of 32 double plays.
- Shortstop for the Lake County Captains (Indians).
- Tena, a 20-year-old international free agent out of San Cristobal, Dominican Republic, was signed by the Indians on July 2, 2017, as an international free agent.
- After Ke’Bryan Hayeswon three consecutive Rawlings Gold Glove Awards from 2017-19, Jared Triolo extended the trend of Pirates minor leaguers earning a Rawlings Gold Glove Award at third base to four years with his performance.
- Triolo, a 23-year-old out of the University of Houston, was taken by the Pirates in the Competitive Balance Round B (72nd overall) in the 2019 Major League Baseball Draft.
- Pache, 22, was signed by the Braves on July 4, 2015, as an international free agency out ofSanto Domingo Centro, Dominican Republic.
- Brenton Doyle, an outfielder with the Spokane Indians (Rockies), has 13 outfield assists and 157 putouts in 83 games for the team.
- Michael Harris II, an outfielder with the Rome Braves, recorded 10 outfield assists and had a total of 216 chances in 92 games.
Adley Rutschman, catcher for the Norfolk Tides (Orioles), participated in 82 games behind the plate and handled 887 chances over 701.1 innings.
Drey Jameson, a right-handed pitcher for the Amarillo Sod Poodles (Diamondbacks), collected 24 total chances in 110.2 innings thrown for both Hillsboro and Amarillo.
Minor League Baseball Facts and Figures There are 120 clubs in Minor League Baseball spanning four classification levels (Low-A, High-A, Double-A, and Triple-A) that are associated with the Major League Baseball’s 30 teams (Low-A, High-A, Double-A, and Triple-A).
Minor League Baseball games are held on Saturdays and Sundays.
Follow Minor League Baseball on social media platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter.
The Rawlings Gold Glove Award® is a registered trademark of Rawlings Sporting Goods Company, Inc., which is owned by the company.
It is not acceptable to shorten, abbreviate, or otherwise misrepresent the name.
For further information, please see Rawlings.com.
Regarding Rawlings Rawlings Athletic Products Company, Inc.
Rawlings is a genuine worldwide sports brand that has been trusted by generations of sportsmen of all abilities since its founding in 1887.
In addition, Rawlings is the Official Ball Supplier and Batting Helmet of Major League Baseball®, the official baseball of Minor League BaseballTM and the NCAA®, and the National High School Federation® has approved Rawlings baseball, basketball, football, and softball for use in its programs.
In order to obtain further information, please visit Rawlings.comor call (314) 819-2800. SOURCE Rawlings; Minor League Baseball; Minor League Baseball
There will be grumbling when the Rawlings Gold Glove Award winners are revealed on Tuesday night, so now is the time to issue your yearly warning that there will be grumbling when the hardware is presented. When it comes to the Gold Gloves, this is typically the case. Other baseball honors have sparked debate, but no other award has a track record of consistently falling short of expectations quite like the Gold Gloves. For an award that is meant to recognize the finest defensive players in the game, it has certainly fallen short of that goal on a number of occasions throughout the years.
- However, if there is a silver lining, it is the fact that the process of selecting the Gold Glove Award recipients is moving in the correct path at this time.
- There has been some discussion about how the selection process will be different this year, and this piece is another thing that has been delayed to some degree.
- If you’re seeking for a different perspective on how an already improved process might be made even better, you’ve arrived at the correct spot.
- The only thing they couldn’t do was vote for their own players, which was disappointing.
- That’s one of the things that’s different now.
- The following is a succinct summary of the collaboration’s objectives: The Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) will create an enlarged statistical resource guide to complement the Rawlings Gold Glove Award votes that are delivered to big league managers and coaches each year.
- The SDI will be used as a “apples-to-apples” statistic to assist evaluate the greatest defensive players in baseball, and it will be used exclusively in the selection procedures for the Rawlings Gold Glove Award and Rawlings Platinum Glove Award.
In August, Rawlings and SABR released an official list of the individuals who will serve on the research committee, as well as the method they had devised for adding statistical data into the process. Here is a list of the names, along with their respective rankings.
- Committee members include: Vince Gennaro, president of the Society of American Baseball Research and author ofDiamond Dollars: The Economics of Winning in Baseball
- Sean Forman, founder of Baseball-Reference.com
- John Dewan, owner of Baseball Info Solutions
- Bo Moon, executive vice president and co-founder ofBloombergSports
- Chris Dial, author and recognized expert on defensive metrics
- Michael Humphreys, author of Wizardry: Baseball’s All-Time Greatest Fielders Revealed
John Dewan, he ofFielding Biblefame, is unquestionably the most well-known of the group’s seven stars. Having said that, anyone who is familiar with the sabermetric Illuminati should be able to identify him, as well as a handful of the other members. When it comes to the SABR Defensive Index, what these seven gentlemen have devised is something that “draws on and aggregates” five separate statistical data points. Among the three are the following, which are obtained from batted-ball data and location-based data respectively:
- Runs Effectively Defended (RED)
- Defensive Runs Saved (DRS)
- Ultimate Zone Rating (UZR)
Probably the two most well-known and commonly utilized advanced measures for measuring defense are DRS and UZR. Both seek to achieve the same thing with much the same technique, and both are widely used. UZR and DRS are both attempts to measure how many “runs” a player is worth on defense in comparison to the average player, either above or below the average player. For both measures, play-by-play data from Baseball Info Solutions is used to calculate their results, with the “zones” where players play and what happens inside those zones taking into consideration what could/should happen within those zones being taken into consideration.
Anyone who is interested in the specifics of how UZR came to be may read FanGraphs’ extensive explanation of the process.
In terms of the RED metric, I’ve been unable to locate a detailed explanation of how it works thus far.
The SDI’s other two measures, which are derived from play-by-play data, are also derived from this data.
- Total Zone Rating (TZ)
- Defensive Regression Analysis (DRA)
Hardball Times has a primer on DRA that you may read. The following is a summary of the document: DRA.systematically examines and analyzes the statistically significant links between traditional, publicly accessible pitching and fielding statistics and the actual amount of runs allowed by a club in the regular season. Formulas are generated by DRA that allow us to estimate the amount of runs saved or allowed by pitchers and fielders (a) in relation to the league average and (b) independently of one another.
Fans may learn more about Total Zone Rating by visiting FanGraphs and Baseball-Reference.
Individually, the five numbers can present an entirely different image of a player’s defensive worth than they do collectively.
The SDI, according to aFAQ on the SABR website, is comprised of five statistics that measure a fielder’s range, throwing arm, sure-handedness, ability to turn double plays (for SS and 2B), ability to convert bunts into outs (primarily for P, C, 3B, and 1B), scoops of throws in the dirt (1B), as well as the number of “excellent” and “poor” fielding plays made by the player.
- The catching of balls in the dirt, as well as stolen bases and being caught stealing, are included in the ratings of catchers.
- (At the moment, pitch framing by catchers is not included in the defensive measures that make up the SDI.) It should be noted that the five indicators that make up the SDI are not all assigned the same level of importance.
- The reason for this is because the latter employs a “more broad approach” when measuring defensive performance.
- The following is SABR’s explanation: The SDI (which is stated in the amount of runs a fielder “saves” his team) has been converted into 30 “votes” for each Rawlings Gold Glove Award that has been given out by the committee in a straightforward manner.
- The remaining 75% of the votes come from the managers and coaches’ ballots.
- That’s the short version — or as short as I can make it — of how things have altered in the last several years.
- Why This Is a Positive Development Rafael Palmeiro earned his second Gold Glove in 1998, becoming the first player from Cuba to do so.
/Photo courtesy of Getty Images There was nothing wrong with the initial choice to allow managers and coaches from both leagues vote on who the top defensive players in the industry were, and that decision was not reversed.
It’s no surprise that the Gold Gloves have shifted from being awarded to the greatest defensive players to being awarded to, well, other things.
And once the voters were enamored with a particular player, they tended to keep the Gold Gloves coming at a steady pace.
Another commonly heard quip is that a particular player didn’t hit well enough to receive a Gold Glove award for his efforts.
In addition, the statement regarding Gold Gloves being awarded to good hitters is correct.
I’m aware of this since I’ve overheard coaches discussing it.
That completely astounds me.
Particularly in this day and age, in which advanced defensive analytics have emerged from the shadows, this is especially true.
But here we are in 2013, and everything has changed.
It is sufficient in and of itself to have the numbers affect the voting.
Despite this, there are several flaws in the system.
When there were difficulties with the list of finalists, it was the first indicator that something was wrong.
It is not known how the finalists fared in the SDI in 2013, although they did well in 2012.
In contrast, after spending the time to compare the list of finalists to the testimony of Defensive Runs Saved and Ultimate Zone Rating, I can speak for the fact that there aren’t many issues to be found with the selection of finalist.
Consider the case of Mike Napoli, the first baseman for the Boston Red Sox.
Despite this, he is not a finalist for the Gold Glove Award.
Davis isn’t the only Orioles player to be named to the Gold Glove finalist list that has raised eyebrows.
Then there’s Juan Lagares of the New York Mets, who plays center field.
Despite this, Lagares was passed over for the award over Denard Span and Andrew McCutchen, who, according to the stats, were very excellent but not outstanding on defense in 2013.
In the National League, D.J.
You are allowed to express your own dissatisfactions, but they are the most significant because of what they reveal about the voting process.
The fact that Jones, Markakis, Span, McCutchen, Beltre, and Ellis — all six of whom have already won Gold Gloves or are widely regarded as outstanding defensive players — are among the finalists indicates that reputation is still a factor in this competition.
An award that recognizes excellence in defense should be concerned only with excellence in defense.
Because statistics are the only thing that can be used to objectively evaluate defense, the simplest solution to resolve the situation would be to simply provide the SDI the exclusive authority in the subject.
To go as far as to make the SDI count for 100 percent of the selection process, however, would be absurd, as would awarding the MVP to the player with the greatest WAR, which would be as absurd.
Alternatively, how about 50% SDI and 50% votes from managers and coaches?
The Gold Gloves would measure defense in the manner in which it is best evaluated: half on data and half on the eye test if it came down to it.
As to whether or not this is even conceivable, there is some disagreement.
It was developed by the most qualified individuals, who focused on the most relevant statistics.
If they come to the conclusion that the SDI has to change in order to remain relevant, they have already committed to doing so in the future.
When asked whether managers and coaches would examine the SDI when it came time to vote, Tampa Bay Rays managerJoe Maddon told theLos Angeles Times, “There will be those who will look at it.” Maddon is also the manager of the Los Angeles Dodgers.
Managers and coaches are provided statistical resource guides that include more than just the SDI, but there isn’t much more than that.
With so much reliance placed on the information provided by the eyes, just providing managers and coaches with a list of figures will only encourage them to turn their heads a short amount of the time.
The ideal method would entail managers and coaches being supplied with the five SDI data broken down individually, as well as written descriptions of how the scores were arrived at in the first place.
For example, in Volume III of TheFielding Bible, John Dewan —who, once again, is in charge of The Fielding Bible, which is responsible for the Defensive Runs Saved statistic —was able to be rather precise about Adam Jones.
As Dewan points out, Jones frequently allows runners to advance further than the average centerfielder on low-velocity fly balls hit into the gaps and by mishandling balls after they have been hit by pitches.
Finally, their ultimate selections would represent a culmination of the best of both worlds, if possible.
Then perhaps the Gold Gloves will finally be awarded only to those players who have demonstrated the greatest deserving of them, without any questions asked.
For the time being, the process will continue as is. It’s not perfect, but at least the Gold Gloves have caught up with modern times. If you want to talk baseball, hit me up on Twitter.
Why the MLB Gold Glove Award Is the Biggest Farce of End-Year Awards Season
Was Adam Jones truly the greatest fielding center fielder in the American League? Image courtesy of Al Bello/Getty Images Criticizing The Gold Glove Awards in Major League Baseball are selecting the low-hanging fruit. It’s the equivalent of shooting fish in a barrel. It is bullying the fragile child who is walking on crutches. That’s something I understand. Baseball should hold the Gold Glove Award to a high level if it intends to market it as a big end-of-season accolade, determined by MLB players and managers who are presumably more knowledgeable than reporters since they are directly involved in the game.
- What is the point of having these prizes if they aren’t going to be used?
- When it comes to choosing their picks, various voters use different criteria.
- Instead, we could just go to FanGraphs and pick out the leaders in Ultimate Zone Rating, then choose the man at the top of the list from that list of leaders.
- However, it would be beneficial to be aware of some of the requirements.
- Perhaps players and managers would not be interested in the end, but certainly someone might be found who would be interested in appearing on camera over the summer.
- Perhaps we’d discover that they, like so many of us, base their decisions on viewing highlights on ESPN and MLB Network.
- Hear me out here for a second—isn’t this meant to be a defense award?
- Hardcore fans, on the other hand, would love to know if a player or manager mentioned any of the analytical analytics that we are more interested in these days.
- Or what if they somehow disclosed data or information that an organization relies on but that is not generally available to the public?
- But here’s the thing: we’re in desperate need of something.
- Alternatively, explain why what we observe on the field is not represented in the final vote results for these awards, if at all possible.
Even if Mike Trout, of the Los Angeles Angels, is widely regarded as the superior center fielder, if only because of his highlight-reel grabs — and despite the fact that UZR rates him as the much superior defensive player – failing to win the award for the top defender at his position is an issue.
- After all, why should we take the Gold Glove Awards seriously if the awards itself do not appear to be taken seriously?
- According to UZR, Michael Bourn of the Atlanta Braves was the best fielding center fielder in Major League Baseball this season.
- Is it possible that Pittsburgh Pirates center fielder Andrew McCutchen won the National League Gold Glove because his batting average, on-base percentage, slugging percentage, and on-base plus slugging % all rated among the league’s top three?
- Is it the same for Chase Headley, who won the National League Gold Glove at third base over David Wright, as it is for David Wright?
- Is the Gold Glove, in essence, a consolation reward for the team?
- Is that the true nature of what’s going on here?
- I agree with you.
- However, by establishing these awards, MLB (and Rawlings, to be precise) is stating that the sport is important.
- The information may be found on a player’s profile page at Baseball-Reference.
- However, are the Gold Glove Awards regarded as seriously as they should be?
- In the evening of Tuesday, the RallyCross racing on ESPN2 took precedence over the announcements (Oct.
After all, the presentation had the production value of a low-budget cable-access show, complete with goofy game-show music, Steve Berthiaume and John Kruk standing at the podium in front of trophies, and cricket-chirping quiet while former baseball stars opened envelopes to reveal their prizes.
In order to maintain any kind of credibility, MLB Network should make the announcements next year. Or, you know, simply give the prizes to the guys who are the greatest on the defensive side of the ball. That would also be beneficial. Follow Ian Casson on Twitter at @iancasson.
Gold Glove Award for Catchers
The Gold Glove Award was established in 1957 by the Rawlings organization, located in St. Louis, to recognize the eighteen finest fielders in the world at their respective positions. Rawlings selected the winner based on a mix of defensive statistics as well as visual effect, and the victor was presented with a huge gold glove. The voting is presently carried out by the managers and coaches of each Major League club, who are not permitted to make their own player selections at this time. It is our pleasure to give a full list of Rawlings Gold Glove Award winners for the catcher’s position, courtesy of Baseball Almanac.
They were discussing his style of play during the game.
It is more about making a difference off the field than it is about making a difference on the field.” Edgar Martinez is a writer and poet.
He was inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame on his first vote after winning ten straight Gold Gloves from 1968 to 1977.
He was also inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame on his first ballot, much like his predecessor.
Let us know what you think about Baseball Fever.
A Gold Glove Award was given to each of the three players during their debut seasons: Johnny Bench in 1968, Carlton Fisk in 1972, and Charles Johnson in 1995.