How Do You Sell Baseball Cards

Looking to Sell Baseball Cards? Here’s How (and Where) to Do It

“Can you tell me how I can sell my baseball cards?” It’s a question that we get asked by people all around the country who call us for help. What they truly mean, or what they ask as a follow-up inquiry, is, “Where can I sell my baseball cards?” or anything along those lines. We’re fairly excellent at assisting these individuals, and we’ll give you with a few crucial actions as well as answers to those same queries on this page. Before you begin, you should double-check your deck to make sure you understand what cards you have.

Although they may not be in the finest of shape, most old cards have some monetary worth.

Older baseball cards and other sports cards, on the other hand, have a thriving secondary market (generally cards manufactured before 1980).

The value of your cards will be determined by a number of variables, including the demand for them and the condition in which they are found.

Most local sports card dealers may be interested in purchasing your collection, but only if they believe they will be able to generate a profit on it soon.

A globally recognized dealer who has the financial means and client base to pay you more for your cards than the local card store might be a great choice for you to consider.

Sell Your Vintage Sports Cards For Cash

Fill out the free assessment form provided below: Each collection is unique, and each seller has his or her own set of objectives, but there are certain fundamental procedures that anyone, even a total newbie, may take in order to be able to sell sports cards. Follow the procedures outlined below to acquire a better understanding of what you have, what condition it is in, what grade it may receive, and how much it has recently sold for. From there, you may choose which selling path is the most appropriate for you, as well as the advantages and disadvantages of each.

Identify exactly which sports cards are in your collection and where they came from.

Look for stats, manufacturer, and copyright date

Each card should have the year and manufacturer printed on it. If you’re not sure what year a card is from, have a look at the back of the card. If a player’s statistics are provided, search for the year that was indicated on the player’s statistics page. It is nearly often the case that the card is from the next year. As an example, if the back of the card has statistics that stretch all the way back to 1955, the card is from 1956. In addition, look for a copyright date and the name of the maker on the back of the card in the fine print.

The reverse of a Topps Mickey Mantle baseball card from 1958.

For example, you may Google “Mickey Mantle Topps150” to find out the card you’re looking for in this situation. You can tell it’s a Topps card since it has the letters T.C.G. on the right side, which stands for Topps Chewing Gum (highlighted here in yellow).

Use Google to figure out the year (and brand)

You can search for the player’s name and card number on Google, as well as part of the information on the back that is in quotation marks, if there are no statistics, no copyright date, and you are unable to ascertain the year and/or the brand. It is possible that the text will include a recap of the player’s career or possibly some advertisement for cigarette or sweets companies. This is the most likely method of obtaining information on the card. If you’re having trouble narrowing down your options, try using Google Images or even YouTube.

Determine what era your cards are from

If a set was made before WWII (1941) and after WWII (1945), it is termed vintage; if it was made before WWII (1945), it is considered pre-war; and anything made after 1980 is considered contemporary. If the cards are in good shape, antique and pre-war collections often fetch a far greater price than current collections.

Identify the stars of your collection

The monetary worth of any set or collection of cards is exactly proportionate to the number of star cards that are included in the set or collection in question. A collection of ten baseball cards including three superstars is often worth more than a collection of one hundred baseball cards featuring only one superstar. However, there are a few notable exceptions, such as Old Judges and T206s. If you are unable to correctly identify all of the superstars in your collection, you may find yourself selling your cards for far less than you should have done.

  • The greatest Major League Baseball players of all time
  • The greatest NBA players of all time
  • The greatest NFL players of all time
  • The greatest NHL players of all time

Having a group of these men together may result in something very unique and memorable. Once you’ve determined what you have, when it was made, and which celebrities are involved, you’ll be well on your way to calculating the worth of your collection. A Bowman from 1949 Jackie Robinson was one of his most sought baseball cards. Examine the condition of your playing cards in Step 2. Make every effort to determine the condition of your playing cards. If you’re successful in identifying issues, your prospective buyer will very certainly do the same (and probably others as well).

Corner wear, creases, surface scuffs, off-centering, paper loss, being out of focus, and writing on a baseball card are all examples of faults that can occur on baseball cards.

Vintage and prewar cards were printed utilizing outdated printing procedures and equipment, and as a result, they typically include print flaws, centering difficulties, and miscuts.

Store your cards safely

Once you’ve recognized your cards and assessed their condition, make sure to store the most valuable ones in plastic sleeves, toploaders, or plastic sheets in binders or albums to protect them from being damaged. This will guarantee that they are not subjected to any additional wear and tear, as well as that the value of your cards is maintained and protected. One of Tom Seaver’s rookie cards from 1967 Topps, with some corner wear and centering difficulties. Step three: Become acquainted with the grading system.

Third-party specialists such as the Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA), Sports Card Guarantee (SGC), and Beckett all assist individuals in determining the worth of vintage sports cards and memorabilia by authenticating cards and establishing a standardized standard for condition for all items.

  • The better the grade, the higher the monetary value of the card.
  • You should not, however, get your cards graded unless absolutely necessary.
  • Step 4: Review recent eBay sales results.
  • In order to achieve the greatest outcomes, provide condition information as well.
  • If you look at previous final selling prices for similar cards on eBay, you’ll have a good indication of how much the card is worth.
  • The majority of dealers will most likely offer you between 50 and 60 percent of the most recent final sale prices, if not less.

Recent sales of a search for “T206 Lajoie” have been found. Take note that the sale prices for sold products are displayed in green (as opposed to black). Step 5: Investigate other avenues for selling your cards.

Selling on eBay

Selling on eBay is one of the first options that most people think of when they think about selling. Although this can be a realistic choice for those with previous experience, it is not recommended for those who are less experienced. Actually, we discourage people from selling on eBay so frequently that we established a page titled “7 Reasons Why You Should NOT Try to Sell Your Cards on eBay” to help them.

Selling on Craigslist

Many individuals consider Craigslist to be the next best option after eBay when it comes to selling their card collection. This is also not always the most optimal strategy to use. Craigslist advertisements will restrict your potential purchasers to those in your immediate vicinity, and there is always the possibility of being ripped off in one way or another. Even if you are successful in finding a buyer through Craiglist, you will almost certainly be able to obtain a greater selling price by selling your home elsewhere.

Selling to a dealer

Until recently, you could locate a baseball card dealer in almost any town in the United States of America. However, with the bursting of the baseball card bubble in the late 1990s and early 2000s, card dealers have become fewer and farther between. The number of big dealers that acquire collections from all over the country and the world has shrunk dramatically in recent years, particularly when it comes to collections of antique and prewar cards. It doesn’t matter if it’s here with us or with another respectable dealer; we strongly advise selling to a professional who makes their livelihood doing this.

  1. You’ll find detailed information on our purchasing procedure further down on this page.
  2. In order to deliver your products to one of our five evaluation locations, we provide a variety of shipping choices.
  3. If your collection has a high monetary value, we will cover all shipping costs.
  4. While we recognize that some people may be uncomfortable sending in a valuable collection of sports cards and memorabilia, we also understand that others may be.
  5. If you do not live within driving distance of our office but have a valuable or rare collection that cannot be shipped, our team of specialists will fly out to you for a free evaluation at your convenience.
  6. What we are looking for We’ll buy your baseball cards and memorabilia if they have any monetary worth.
  7. We are constantly on the lookout for (pre-1980) sports and non-sports trading cards.
  8. We also enjoy trading cards that feature celebrities or Hall of Famers, as well as high-grade cards that feature everyday players.
  9. Just Collect purchases a variety of other collectibles in addition to sports cards.
  10. Only in recent months have we spent hundreds of thousands of dollars collecting historic sports collections from people all around the United States and Canada.

We want to continue this trend in the future. Get in touch with us You can reach us by phone at 732-828-2261 from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m., Monday through Friday. Additionally, you may contact us by email at [email protected]

How To Sell Baseball Cards For Top Dollar: The Expert Guide

In my many years of selling baseball cards, there’s one thing I’ve learned: the marketplace you select is really important. What exactly do I mean by this? Every sort of baseball card collection has a proper and improper market, and vice versa. Depending on the collection, each sort of buyer will be attracted to it. The most important thing is to find the correct buyers for your collection. For that reason, if you have baseball cards available for sale, this article will lead you through the various selling strategies.

Ross Uitts is the proprietor.

If this is the case, please complete the form below and I will contact you as soon as possible.

The first step is to create a plan.

Identify The Cards You Have

This may appear to be self-evident. However, it is the most important stage of them all. You’re in luck, because the hobby has split cards into three primary categories to make it easier to instantly recognize them and determine their relative values:

  • Prior to 1945, pre-war prints were produced
  • Vintage prints were produced between 1946 and 1979
  • And modern prints were produced between 1980 and current.

For each section, there is a unique collection of qualities that distinguishes it from the others in terms of both appearance and monetary worth. Let’s take a deeper look at what’s going on.

Pre-War Baseball Cards (Printed Prior to 1945)

It is possible that some of the most expensive baseball cards you will ever come upon were printed before World War II. Cards featuring luminaries like Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Christy Mathewson, Honus Wagner and “Shoeless” Joe Jackson may be found in this section of the pastime, to mention a few examples. They are typically distinguished by their smaller sizes, gorgeous color artwork (or black and white photography), and reverse sides that had adverts for cigarette or confectionery firms. It is not uncommon for cards of Hall of Famers and movie stars from this era to be worth thousands of dollars, especially if they are in excellent condition.

These are often instances in which a card has a printing problem or was taken from manufacturing early for whatever reason, and only a small number of cards survived.

  • It will be completely blank, and it will not have any statistics. a commercial for the firm that made it will be included
See also:  How To Improve Hitting In Baseball

Vintage Baseball Cards (Printed From 1946 – 1979)

Famous players like as Mickey Mantle, Hank Aaron, Willie Mays, and Roberto Clemente are the driving force for this sector of the hobby. Topps finally came to dominate this era, defeating competitors such as Bowman, Fleer, and Leaf along the way. Despite the fact that there were still a few black and white issues available during this time period, vintage cards are noted for their magnificent color artwork and photos. In addition, the 1957 Topps baseball card set introduced the usual card measurements of 2-1/2 by 3-1/2 inches that we are now accustomed to seeing on baseball cards.

Cards from non-star players, even ones that are considered common, can be worth a lot of money depending on which card they are and how well they are preserved.

When in doubt, one method to know is to look at the stat box for the previous season and add one year to it because cards were printed for the next season. For example, if the final stat line on the card was from 1958, you would conclude that the card was manufactured in 1959.

Modern Baseball Cards (Printed From 1980 – Current)

I began collecting baseball cards as a child in the late 1980s, and I still retain the majority of them to this very day. However, unfortunately, as a result of the large print runs of this era, the market is currently overrun with them. Because of the high volume of manufacture, it is almost assured that a card from this time period will be worthless. An item of significant worth in the contemporary era is generally the rookie card of an active or upcoming Hall of Fame player, in perfect condition, or it must be personally autographed by the player himself in order to be considered valuable.

Those exceptions, on the other hand, are exceedingly rare.

  • It is important to know whose player is on the card, how old it is, what condition it is in, how scarce it is (errors, variants, and so on), as well as whether or not the card has been properly graded.

There are a variety of peculiarities to this pastime that might influence the value of a card. Fortunately for you, we’ve published a full page about how to assess the worth of your baseball cards, which you can read here: How to Determine the Value of Your Baseball Cards Baseball Card Values – What Are They Worth? When it comes to selling your baseball card collection, my experience has shown me that two elements are important to consider:

  • What kind of cards you’re selling (pre-War, vintage, modern)
  • How much you’re charging
  • How fast you need to get them off your hands

Again, if you are selling cards that were printed between 1879 and 1979 and want more assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me using this form. Ross Uitts is the proprietor. Do you have any sports cards that were printed between 1879 and 1979 that you would want to sell? If this is the case, please complete the form below and I will contact you as soon as possible. Alternatively, you may reach me by phone or text at 305-803-8626. Let’s take a look at the three most frequent methods of selling baseball cards, as well as the advantages and disadvantages of each.

Private Online Auction Houses

Is your collection mostly comprised of pre-War or antique trading cards? You must ask yourself if you can afford to wait a few months to sell your items. Selling your cards through a private auction house may be an excellent choice in this case. There are a number of private online auction companies that specialize solely in the sale of vintage sports cards, and they are excellent at what they do. As a result, they already have a network of collectors who are anxious to make a purchase, and they actively market to them through email, print catalogues, and even personal phone calls.

The disadvantage is that there are so many of them nowadays that determining which ones are competent and trustworthy might be tough to determine.

However, if you have the financial means to wait in order to optimize your sale prices, I would advise you to go this option instead. Pros

  • There is a lot of publicity about your cards. Collectors who are eagerly awaiting their turn
  • You will not have to worry with shipping
  • It could take several weeks or months to sell
  • Only a few companies provide fixed-price selling formats. Some businesses are untrustworthy
  • For example,

Card DealersShops

If you have a collection of pre-War or vintage cards (or perhaps some current cards) that you want to sell but you need to do it fast, this is probably your best bet for success. A dealer or card store can sell your item immediately at a price that has been agreed upon by bargaining with them in person, over email, or over the phone. This choice, however, might be challenging if you prefer to conduct business face-to-face because there aren’t many dealers and stores around anymore. Another significant disadvantage is that it might be quite difficult to locate a dealer or business owner whom you can put your faith in.

I’ve heard innumerable examples of folks who have been taken advantage of.

In all honesty, I would only recommend it if you are desperate for time.

  • It’s probable that this will be your best option if you have a collection of pre-War or vintage cards (or perhaps some current cards) that you need to sell immediately. A dealer or card store can sell your item immediately at a price that has been agreed upon by bargaining with them in person, over email, or over the telephone. However, because there aren’t as many dealers and stores around anymore, it might be tough to complete this transaction in person if you choose. Another significant disadvantage is that it might be quite difficult to locate a dealer or business owner whom you can put your faith in. The majority of buyers will provide between 50 and 60 percent of the market value for your cards, with some willing to go even lower. Many others have told me about being duped, and I’ve heard many examples myself. Taking this method necessitates extreme caution and much preparation. Unless you need to get somewhere quickly, I wouldn’t suggest it. Pros
  • Some traders are dishonest
  • Others are dishonest. Prices that are far below market value
  • Many are not in your immediate vicinity


It doesn’t matter what kind of cards you have in your collection; selling them on eBay might be a terrific alternative, especially if you need to sell your cards fast. With eBay, you may sell your cards in a variety of formats, including the following:

  • Auction
  • Fixed-price
  • Fixed-price with the ability to accept offers
  • Fixed-price with the capacity to accept offers

Because thousands of collectors purchase and sell on eBay every day, you have a tremendous amount of exposure with this platform. One significant disadvantage, on the other hand, is the amount of time and money you will be required to devote to the project on your own. You’ll need a scanner in order to take professional photographs, and you’ll be responsible for overseeing the full shipping procedure on your own. There is also the chance of purchasers defrauding you in a variety of methods at any point in time.


  • Different sales forms are available
  • A large audience reach is available
  • And cards may be sold fast.
  • Possibilities of purchasing fraud
  • Managing images and listings
  • Managing delivery and processing

Where Can I Sell My Baseball Cards for Cash?

It’s an often asked question. “May you tell me where I can sell my baseball cards?” We hope that this website may be of use to you, whether you want cash or are simply fed up with the amount of room they take up. Whoever is wanting to sell baseball and other sports cards must first determine what they have in their possession before they can proceed. There are several crucial questions to consider, and answering them may help you determine the best approach to liquidate your sports card collection—or even whether it is even a possibility.

The market for older baseball cards and related memorabilia (usually dating back to the 1980s) is, on the other hand, thriving.

So, what are your choices for locating a buyer for your trading card collection?

Even while there are still card stores around, the number of them has much reduced compared to previous years.

Not every card or set is in high demand, and others aren’t even in demand at all at certain times of year. Please do not hesitate to contact them or to attend a card show (you may have to travel a bit but you can find card show listingshere).

Sell Your Vintage Sports Cards for Cash

A better choice is to sell your antique baseball, football, basketball, or hockey cards to individuals who specialize in buying them, and there are various possibilities for doing so on the internet. You may contact our colleagues at Inc. via the contact form provided straight below. Please complete the form thoroughly and describe what you have, and someone will contact you as soon as possible. IMPORTANT: Most of the time, they are solely interested in obtaining high-quality vintage cards (pre-1980s), however they will accept high-value modern-era cards as well.

Sell Your Sports Cards Inc. would appreciate it if you would contact them. Please complete this form and someone will contact you as soon as possible. Thank you for your time.


If you’re feeling particularly ambitious, you may try offering your items on oneBay’s selling site. Make certain to describe your cards in detail and to include high-quality photographs. If you have antique cards that actually seem like they just came out of the pack (with no corner wear, stains, or creases, and that are well-centered), you may want to consider having your top-performing cards graded. A good rule of thumb is to rate legendary cards in somewhat lower grades, such as Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Hank Aaron and other Hall of Famers from the 1960s onward, in order to avoid overvaluing them.

Compare Your Cards

Sports card purchasers are a well-informed group of individuals. In order to determine what cards have sold for, they will consult online pricing guide services as well as completed transactions on eBay, and you should do the same. In order to determine the quality of your antique cards, compare them to those that have sold in the last several months (look for the’sold’ search option on the left-hand side of eBay). You’ll be able to get a basic sense of where the market is. Dealers will most likely offer a portion of that amount, since they will need to earn a profit on the transaction.

Auction House Option

If you are trying to sell whole or almost complete sets, as well as pre-1960s stars in large quantities from the mid-1960s onward, you may also contact an auction business that specializes in sports memorabilia for advice and assistance. They have advertisements on our sites that may be found at the top, bottom, and sides of our pages. All of these businesses are well-established. The older, the better, and high-grade material, particularly graded vintage, is of particular interest to collectors.

It doesn’t hurt to inquire, and their catalogs are a lot of fun to browse through.

Your 1980s and 90s Cards Aren’t Likely Worth Much

Perhaps you still enjoy sports but prefer to collect autographs and other sports memorabilia rather than trading cards, and you hoped to utilize the earnings from the sale of your old cards to fund something else. There aren’t many people who are interested in buying old baseball cards and other sports cards from the 1980s and 1990s since they were created in such large quantities to suit customer demand during that time period. The majority of your collection may have been acquired between the mid-1980s and the early 1990s, which means you may be forced to just sell them at a garage sale and take whatever you can get.even if that’s only a few dollars.

Higher-end rookie cards of players such as Ken Griffey Jr., Frank Thomas, Derek Jeter, Mike Trout, Michael Jordan, and a few other marquee players may have some value—but only if they are graded by a reputable company such as Professional Sports Authenticator(PSA), Beckett (BGS), or Sportscard Guaranty(SGC) and receive a 9 or 10 rating.

It’s a good idea to look at other cards that have sold in order to get a sense of what they are worth.

Other Do-It-Yourself Selling Outlets

You may also try COMC, a service that allows you to simply place your cards within penny sleeves, fill out a form, and mail them in to be evaluated. The COMC then takes care of scanning the cards and uploading them to their website for you. Once you receive an email confirming that your order has been executed, you may log in and adjust the pricing. You can compare the cards offered by others and undercut or equal their prices in order to increase the likelihood of selling your cards. There is a cost of around 30 cents each card, so be sure you have cards that are worth selling before you list them (pre-1980s or popular sets from themodern era in all sports).

See also:  What Is Balking In Baseball

Simply look for them on the internet and join one to learn more and ask questions.

You’d be shocked at how inexpensively you can get certain cards that you’ve been looking for on eBay as well.

The Complete Guide To Selling Your Baseball Card Collection

The information in this article will assist you in getting the most money possible for your baseball card collection if you have a large collection and are unsure how to sell your cards. It may be a good time to sell some of your favorite collections because the value of vintage sports cards has been growing at an exponential rate in recent years. It is possible to be intimidated by the process of selling your cards; as a result, we’ve attempted to describe all of the most critical procedures in the most thorough manner possible.

So, without further ado, please find below the table of contents: Selling a Baseball Card Collection: A Comprehensive How-To Manual

Are Baseball Cards Still Worth Money?

Baseball cards, as well as all other sports cards, are in high demand now, and the industry is thriving. In reality, because of the broad availability of high-speed internet connection and a variety of online marketplaces, there has never been a more established and liquid market than the one that now exists. Cards may be sold quite simply and for close to their full worth, depending on the demand for the particular card in question. The introduction of grading firms and the accompanying population statistics has made it quite simple for collectors to gain an estimate of the amount of supply that exists for any given card on the market.

  • If you’re thinking about selling your collection, this reference guide will teach you all you need to know about everything from organizing your cards to identifying your cards, deciding whether or not to get your cards graded, and finding the best sites to sell your cards.
  • In recent years, data has made it simpler for collectors to buy and sell cards online or in person, with far less unpredictability in cost when compared to previous years.
  • We can see in the chart below that an index of PWCC cards has beaten the S P 500 by a significant margin over the past several years.
  • PWCC graphic comparing the performance of its 500 Index to that of the S P 500 This consistency of the hobby as a result of improved data has resulted in a more organized market.
  • Some people have also begun to use credit cards for purchases that they would not have made a decade ago because of the system’s dependability.

Because of this, the pastime has taken on the feel of a “stock market,” for better or worse, which is probably what has contributed to the surge in the value of cards in recent years.

How Do I Identify My Baseball Cards?

Before you can sell your collection, you must first have a thorough grasp of the cards that you truly have. Before attempting to sell their collection, I would advise collectors to take some time to make an inventory of everything in their collection. You should use this section to help you identify your baseball cards if you have a collection of baseball cards and are unsure of what you have in front of you. First, look at the reverse side of the card. There is almost certainly some type of manufacturer and date information on the back of the card, unless it is an astrip card (which generally has blank backs).

  1. The reverse of a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle baseball card, which is considered to be one of the most valuable baseball cards ever created.
  2. We can tell that we have a ‘Topps Baseball’ card by looking at the bottom of the back, but there is no indication of the year on the back.
  3. And, yes, that is a Topps baseball card from 1952.
  4. Take notice that there is no ’51 Topps’ Mantle in this set.
  5. Many people are unaware of the Google Reverse Image Search feature, which may be used to find images that have been reversed.

It is sufficient to just click on the photo, as demonstrated in the figure below (circled in red) It labeled our 1952 Mantle Back as a ‘Mickey Mantle Rookie Card,’ which is technically not correct because Mantle’s 1951 Bowman is his genuine rookie card; but, it provides us with enough information to determine that this is in fact a 1952 Topps Mantle card.

In other words, regardless of whether you have a 1952 Mickey Mantle or a 1981 Topps Joe Montana, you may use the same procedure with whichever card you happen to have.

How Much Should I Ask For My Card Collection?

To get a general idea of how much your baseball card collection is worth, the most straightforward place to start is eBay. Examination of previous sales of cards on eBay might offer us with an excellent indication of the most recent values on the market. A listing of recent auction sales (including those on eBay) is also provided by PSA, which may be extremely helpful in estimating the current worth of a card. Here’s an example of how to get recent sales data on eBay using the search function.

  1. The search results will display all of the cards that are currently available for purchase.
  2. Click on the ‘Advanced’ text, which is highlighted in red, to proceed.
  3. Note A filter for sold products above $500 was also included because there was a lot of trash showing up in the results, and I know from personal experience that the majority of Jordan rookies sell for more than $500.
  4. We can see that the most recent transaction was a PSA 4 Jordan, which went for $1025 in this case.
  5. Additionally, PSA’s website provides a useful picture of current eBay sales (as well as recent auction sales) for our reference.
  6. For the ‘Michael Jordan Fleer Rookie PSA’ card, I created this website, and the first link is to the PSA Card Facts page.
  7. PSA has made significant enhancements to this section of their website, and they also include a detailed analysis of sales per card grade as well.

Additionally, as shown below, a chart indicating recent sales prices by grade is available. Make sure to read our resource guide on estimating baseball card values for additional information and specifics on the most essential aspects that go into deciding card prices.

Should I Get My Cards Graded Before Selling Them?

Generally speaking, a graded card is worth more than a ‘raw’ card, which is one that has not been evaluated. It goes without saying that there are charges associated with grading (on average, $15 to $20 per hour for bare-bones services). As a result, you must compare the costs against the possible rise in value in the long run. Final analysis will reveal that a graded card collection will sell for greater money than an ungraded collection of the same card kind. If you are wanting to sell your collection as soon as possible, grading your cards may not be in your best interests due to the fact that wait periods have been progressively growing in recent years.

  • Generally speaking, I believe that if anything is worth $100 or more, it is generally worth rating.
  • A lot of collectors who are set builders will decide that they want a completely graded set, which may require evaluating all of the players who aren’t stars.
  • One of my most costly blunders as a beginning vintage collector was submitting several T206 commons to PSA for evaluation.
  • In the event that you purchase a card with the expectation of receiving a PSA 1 (Poor Condition) and it ends up receiving a PSA 3 (VG) or PSA 4 (Excellent Condition), this will only be beneficial (VG-EX).
  • Make sure to check out our resource guide on card grading as well as our advice to determining whether or not you should get your cards professionally graded.

What Is The Best Way To Sell A Sports Card Collection?

EBay is the quickest and most convenient way to sell your cards, however there are costs associated with it. eBay enables users to post up to 50 things for free every month, but there is a 10 percent commission charged on the final sale price of your baseball cards if you decide to sell them. In addition, there is a charge that you must pay to PayPal (.30 + 2.9 percent fee), as well as any shipping expenses that are not paid by the buyer, that you must pay. There is a lot of money involved in these payments.

If you look for a certain sport and era, you’ll most likely come across a large community of people that are involved in card trading.

In most cases, groups will stand behind the individual in issue, and a quick search of a person’s name in the group will provide some further information about their previous postings and transactions.

Forumsand Blowout Cards are cards that have a large amount of information on them.

Despite the fact that I’ve never done it, some card collectors will sell their cards in a Pawn Shop. Unless you’re in a really urgent circumstance, I’d advise against doing so. A local card shop, if one is available, might be more beneficial to card collectors if one is available.

Ten Tips To Help You Get Top Dollar For Your Card Collection

It’s time to discover out what exactly you have in possession! Make a list of everything! We’ve created a Google Sheet to assist you in your endeavor. If you’re selling your cards, that document will come in helpful while you’re working with dealers. The more preparation you put in before you begin the process of selling your cards, the better off you will be in the long run. If you want any assistance in recognizing your cards, please refer to our recommendations for determining what it is that you have.

2. Talk To Card Dealers

Visit a local baseball card show if you have the opportunity. or look for trusted sellers on the internet. At a card show, you might be able to meet someone who is willing to pay exactly what you want in person. My recommendation would be to do some research on the dealer in question. Occasionally, merely putting up “Dealer XYX Scam” or “Dealer XYZ Reviews” can provide you with all of the information you want.

3. Learn About Sports Card Grading

It is recommended that you grade your cards with one of the most respected graders, such as PSA, Beckett, or SGCare. While it is not required to grade your cards, you will often receive more money for higher quality graded cards as opposed to cards that are ‘raw.’ One disadvantage is that, as a result of the increase in demand for card collecting in recent years, the grading businesses are severely backlogged, and you may find yourself waiting months to receive your card behind. Check out our reference guide on grading your sports cards for more information.

4. Have a Price In Mind

Despite the fact that you are unlikely to receive auction price whether you sell to a dealer or at a show, it is crucial to understand the value of your cards. For example, as previously stated, a simple search of completed eBay auctions may be quite helpful in determining the most accurate value of a card. On average, if a card is in great demand, you may expect to receive upwards of 80% of the card’s book value when selling it.

5. Consider Passing On To Heirs If Possible

Vintage baseball cards have outpaced the S P 500 over the course of more than three decades, which may seem absurd. If you have a high-quality collection and aren’t in immediate need of money, it could be worth your while to consider selling it.

See also:  How Old Are Little League Baseball Players

6. Get Educated On The Hobby

Our work on historic sports cards is intended to educate all card collectors, not just those who specialize in sports cards. It’s possible that we have an article on a set or card that you already own. Hopefully, it is included on this list! The more knowledgeable you are about your collection, the greater your chances of not being taken advantage of are. Educate yourself on your collection.

7. Invest In A Scanner For Your Cards

If you have a huge collection of items that you expect to take a long time to sell, it may be worthwhile to invest in a scanning device. One of the most common blunders a seller may do is to provide a potential buyer unclear photographs that aren’t clear enough.

Photos taken with your iPhone can occasionally be successful, but the greater quality of the picture produced by a scanner will almost always yield superior results. There’s a nice debate here about some of the better solutions for digitizing baseball cards that you should check out.

8. Consign Your Cards To An Auction House

You should consider consigning your cards to an auction house if you have a collection of really expensive stuff. We’ve compiled a list of some of the most renowned auction merchants available on the market right now.

9. Facebook Marketplace Is A Free Option

You could consider using Facebook Marketplace to sell your card collection if you want to save money on the transaction. First and foremost, it is completely free, and second, it has a large audience. It is usually more successful on Facebook if you have cards that are local to a certain market, however there are many purchasers trying to scoop up collections as well.

10. Be Careful Of Scammers

If you’re selling your cards to someone online that you haven’t met before, you should proceed with caution. This would mostly comprise social media sites such as Facebook as well as classified advertising sites such as Craigslist and OfferUp. If you take digital payments, be aware that PayPal Goods and Services will charge a fee, but will cover the buyer in the event that something goes wrong with the transaction. I recommend that if you are meeting up with someone, you pick a nearby police station that permits for internet exchanges.

In addition, if you don’t want to deal with all the hassles of putting your items on eBay or dealing with an auction house, there are collectors who will pay top price for high-quality sports cards and set collections.

More information about our purchasing procedure may be found in the sections below:

Selling Your Sports Cards toAll Vintage Cards

Because All Vintage Cards has been buying and selling sports cards since the early 1980’s, we have established ourselves as one of the most respected and trustworthy purchasers in the game. While I advise all sellers to browse around when selling a premium card collection, I can assure you that our offer will be towards the top of the list on a majority of the occasions that you do.

Here’s What All Vintage Cards is Currently Buying

  • Tobacco cards (T series), early candy and gum cards (E series), strip/exhibit cards (W series), and all other pre-war sports cards are included. a collection of Hall of Famers and stars from the first Topps and Bowman sets (1948 through 1975)
  • Stars such as Gretzky, Montana, Brady, Jordan, Russell, Erving, and Chamberlain, among others, have signed key rookie cards. Unopened wax from the 1950s, 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s
  • Complete or partially complete sets of pre-war baseball cards and pre-1960 Bowman/Topps baseball cards
  • Vintage memorabilia such as autographs, jerseys, bats, signed balls, and other memorabilia
  • Vintage basketball, football, and hockey cards in high grades

Submit Your Collection +Get aFree Estimate

Alternatively, you may submit a list of your collection to [email protected] using the submission form provided below.

How to Sell Baseball Cards

Documentation Download Documentation Download Documentation Selling your old baseball collection may be a rewarding and entertaining experience. Because of their sentimental value, some greeting cards are simply not worth parting with at all. Baseball cards have a significant market share in the United States (mostly for cards produced before 1970). The likelihood of someone purchasing your cards increases if you put more effort into the presentation of the cards you are selling.

  1. 1 Sort and arrange your cards. Organize your cards into three separate categories in order to better understand their relative worth. The first group consists of modern cards, which are those that were manufactured between the 1970s and the present time period. Afterwards, you’ll want to look into post-war cards, which are cards that were manufactured between 1948 and 1969. If you have any of these cards, they fall into the final group of pre-war cards, which are cards that were made before to World War II.
  • If you discover that a large number of your cards are current cards, you may not be able to sell them for much money. Modern cards were made in large quantities, and as a result, their monetary worth is quite low.

2 Take good care of your playing cards. Purchase comfortable sleeves for your contemporary playing cards. Use a stronger level of security for your higher-end cards, such as a magnetic case. Cards that have been well-cared for are the only ones that are worth selling.

  • In the event of a fault in the card’s condition, the card’s total worth might be reduced.

Advertisement 3 Consult a Beckett pricing guide for further information. Beckett is a corporation that researches the worth of cards for serious card traders on a regular basis.

To take use of their service, jot down the name, brand, and number of the baseball card. This is not the player’s number; rather, it is the name of the card. To get an approximate approximation, you may either utilize an online edition or find a hard copy of the publication.

  • For example, the ID number on the rookie Barry Bonds Topps card is 12. It is now available on the market for $12 USD.

4 Select the cards that will be sold. Many of the most costly cards in the collection of many passionate card collectors are also the most sentimental for them. Before taking your cards to a card trader or hobby shop to have them examined, decide whether or not they are worth parting with.

  • Before leaving with your Mickie Mantle card, make sure it is in good working order. The sentimental value of a card that is in bad shape may not be worth its replacement cost.
  1. 1 Make a presentation of the card. The cards must be presented in a marketable manner if you wish to sell them separately. Make the card appear more expensive by presenting it in a magnetic card holder. Remove any loose material from the card before inserting it into the holder.
  • The recommendation is to only sell cards separately if they are really rare or extremely valuable. The market typically purchases cards as part of a collection

2Speak with a buyer in your area. Every neighborhood has a “go-to” buyer for vintage playing cards. Consult with local sports businesses that concentrate in memorabilia rather than athletic clothing to find out where to look. Inform them of the sort of cards you are attempting to sell and inquire as to whether they or anybody they know could be interested in purchasing them. 3 Distribute information on the internet. Post classified advertising on Craigslist, eBay, and other venues where greeting cards are sold to generate revenue.

Your best chance of finding what you’re looking for may be on eBay, which has a thriving community of people who know what they’re looking for.

  • Make your post as truthful as possible. Taking high-quality photographs of the real cards will result in a greater number of queries. Make certain that your cards are the center of attention. It is recommended that you make advantage of any highlighting features that are available.

4 Conduct market research and determine the value of your particular cards. Consider looking through the listings of other online vendors who are also selling the exact same card and making a note of the price they are asking for it. If you don’t put the precise price or a lesser price on them when you sell them, they will not sell.

  • Before allowing a dealer to analyze the card, look up the card’s information on the internet. For example, the Topps ID number for Bo Jackson from 1986 is 50T. The card you have is worth around $140 USD on the internet market in good condition
  • Google search for the cards you have. For example, you may look for “Dock Ellis baseball card” on Google. You’ll discover a plethora of information and pricing for the same card you have on the internet

5Make use of a local buyer or a card-buying service. There are businesses available to assist you if you want to avoid the headache of selling your cards on your own. If you do not have a track record of selling, many buyers may be wary of working with you. It is advisable to conduct as much research as possible before presenting your cards to a customer. Advertisement

  1. 1Purchase the necessary presentation materials. A binder is a great way to display a larger collection of cards that have been carefully chosen for display purposes. Purchase a binder and pocket protection pages to keep your documents safe. Obtaining pocket protectors will be easy, as they will be available online or at your local hobby store. 2Hand out your business cards. Sort your baseball cards by brand and year to make them easier to find. Begin with the oldest and most valuable cards and work your way down to the newer and less valuable cards
  2. 3Research similar collections to your own. Decide how much the collection is worth in its whole. Searching for similar collections online to see how much they’re charging may be beneficial in determining your pricing. Take a moment to jot down the names of all of the cards in the collection in the order in which you will be presenting them. This will assist you in determining the value of the item and will inform the buyers of exactly what they are purchasing
  3. 4 Decide on a beginning price for your project. It is always best to demand a price that is slightly higher than what they are truly worth. This will open the door to further discussion and bartering between you and the buyer. Negotiate the most favorable terms possible for your collection. If you are completing the transaction online, collect payment before sending your card collection out or having it picked up by a third party.
  • A service such as PayPal provides a safe and secure method of making and receiving payments online.

Create a new question

  • Question Is it possible to use this strategy for Steam trade cards as well? No, this is only applicable to sports cards that are in tangible form. Question What method would I use to determine the worth of my cards? Bring them to the attention of a card dealer (preferably more than one dealer). The condition in which they are now found would have to be evaluated before they could ascertain their actual value.

Fill in the blanks with your question and email address to be notified when it is answered.SubmitAdvertisement200 characters remaining

  • Take excellent care of your playing cards. They are only valuable for resale if they are in excellent condition. Make your advertisement visually appealing in order to capture everyone’s attention. Your cards are quite nicely described. Never make a false statement regarding their health
  • In order to gain extra money, put cards into plastic cases and sell them in them. Try to keep your rates as affordable as possible and always allow your consumers to bargain

Thank you for submitting a suggestion for consideration! Advertisement

Things You’ll Need

Summarize the articleXIf you want to sell baseball cards, start by categorizing your collection chronologically, because older cards are often worth more money. Additionally, check the quality of your cards because faults reduce the total value of your collection. In good condition, you may use a soft card case for current cards, and a magnetic case for higher-end cards if the cards are in good shape. To determine the value of your cards, use a Beckett pricing guide to obtain an estimate of what they are worth.

Continue reading if you want to understand how to sell a collection of baseball cards.

Thank you to all writers for contributing to this page, which has been read 47,699 times so far.

Did this article help you?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.