How Much Is A Willie Mays Baseball Card Worth

27 Willie Mays Baseball Cards You Need To Own

2 Baseball cards of Willie Mays are among the most highly sought-after in the hobby. The Say Hey Kid is easily one of the all-time greats in Major League Baseball, if not the all-time best, in the eyes of most people. One of the most famous quotes from Harry Jupiter of the San Francisco Chronicle was: “There is no record book that can capture this level of focus, dedication, tenacity, or talent. Willie Mays was a player whose accomplishments could never be measured just in terms of numbers.” His status as one of the most revered baseball players in the sport’s history has made Willie Mays baseball cards some of the most sought-after collectibles in the world of baseball.


Were sports cards manufactured between 1868 and 1975 available for purchase from you?

Alternatively, you may reach me by phone or text at 305-684-6680.

1951 Bowman305 Willie Mays Rookie Card

The 1951 Bowman is the only officially acknowledged Willie Mays rookie card, and it is one of the most precious baseball cards in the hobby, as well as one of the most costly in the history of the sport. A Warren Spahn fastball soared over the left field wall of the Polo Grounds, giving Mays his first Major League hit after an abysmal 0-12 start to his rookie season. Mays would end the season with a.274 batting average, 20 home runs, and 68 RBI, which was enough to earn him the Rookie of the Year honors for the season.

1952 Bowman218

Bowman’s 1952 Bowman is a critical high-number card in the series, and it is also one of Willie’s most difficult cards in general. Even though it’s more harder to come by in high grade, it’s still not quite as popular as his Topps card from the same year, despite being more difficult to get by. To give you an idea of what you may expect, the 1952 Bowman Mays issue is frequently available for less than half the price of the 1952 Topps issue.

1952 Topps261

Due to the fact that it was the first Topps card to feature Willie Mays, this card is very noteworthy among vintage baseball card collectors. Immediately identifiable, the Topps design from 1952 portrays a young Mays with his trademark determined, concentrated expression on his face. The card was released in 1952. After earning the National League Rookie of the Year title in 1952, the United States Army enlisted Mays to serve in the Korean War, causing him to miss the most of the following season.

1953 Topps244

Despite the fact that Mays would miss the whole 1953 season while serving in the Korean War, Topps nonetheless included him on a card that year, although Bowman did not. The 1953 Topps Mays card is possibly the most important card in the whole collection since they are extremely difficult to come across in good grade.

Due to the black border at the bottom of the card being prone to chipping and wear, there have been roughly half as many Mays cards submitted for grading as there have been Mickey Mantle cards because Mays cards were not included in the “discovery” years ago.

1954 Bowman89

Mays would go on to earn his one and only World Series ring during the 1954 season. “The Catch,” an over-the-shoulder grab of a long drive by Vic Wertz of the Cleveland Indians during Game 1 of the 1954 World Series, is remembered as one of Mays’ greatest achievements. His cover for the year 1954 depicts him crouching down with a bat across one leg and a radiant smile.

1954 Topps90

Topps Baseball Cards from 1954 It was Willie Mays’ baseball card that introduced the concept of a double picture. Rather than a larger head image of a smiling Mays, the right side of the card has a smaller action shot of him swinging a baseball bat. Because of the way these cards were cut, centering is frequently a problem, and you’ll also encounter jagged edges on a regular basis. One of the most popular Willie Mays baseball cards among those who collect them is this one.

1955 Bowman184

Roberto Clemente, Sandy Koufax, and Harmon Killebrew’s rookie cards were mysteriously absent from Bowman’s final vintage collection, which was released in 2003. However, they did not forget about Mays while designing the famed television set frame design for this collection. Brown borders on Mays’ Bowman cards are well-known for causing centering and chipping problems, and his 1955 Bowman cards are no exception. Despite the fact that it is not as valuable as his Topps issue from the same year, this card is unquestionably a favorite among card collectors.

1955 Topps194

When Topps issued its first horizontally styled card in 1955, it took a risk by going for a different perspective. In Mays’ case, though, you’ll immediately notice something that isn’t very remarkable about it: his head photo on the 1955 Toppsissue is identical to his head shot on the 1954 Toppsissue. At the very least, the action images on each of the cards were unique. Aside from the duplication, the 1955 Topps edition is one of Mays’ most visually appealing baseball cards.

1956 Topps130

Tell me it ain’t so. What are the chances that Topps will use the same head photo of Willii Maysyet again? They would, without a doubt. But we’ll forgive them for their continual lack of imagination when it comes to head shots because the card itself is still fantastic. Additionally, collectors will receive a fantastic action graphic of Mays sliding into home plate in an attempt to avoid being tagged out.

1957 Topps10

The design of Willie Mays’ Topps baseball card from 1957 is rather plain. The Say Hey Kid is depicted prominently in a batting posture that is both crisp and concentrated. In terms of historical significance, though, this card is noteworthy since it is the final occasion Mays would appear on an officially sanctioned baseball card while wearing a New York Giants uniform before the team relocated to San Francisco the following year.

1958 Topps5

With a brilliant smile and a bright blue background, Willie Mays is shown in a fantastic head photo on the 1958 Topps Willie Mays issue. However, another thing you’ll notice about this card is the white print bubble spots on the blue backdrop, which are normally visible when it’s not properly centered.

This was the first popular card to depict Willie Mays as a Giant, and it depicted the team at their new home in San Francisco for the first time.

1959 Topps50

During the 1959 baseball season, Topps introduced a fantastic design that featured player photos surrounded on top of vibrantly colored backgrounds. The names of the players were also shown in all lower case letters at a diagonal angle across the top of the screen. Mays enthusiasts adore this piece because of its crisp 1959 styling.

1960 Topps200

For the final time during the vintage card period, Topps returned to a horizontal style, including a beautiful action photo of Mays swinging the bat on the left and a larger head shot image of him on the right. Additionally, he is identified by the renowned alternating letter coloring that runs along the bottom of the card, as well as by his position and the team’s information.

1961 Topps150

Topps picked an odd photograph of Mays to be featured on their 1961 release. Mays is represented with a perplexed and nearly blank expression, in contrast to the majority of his earlier cards in which he was smiling. He’s not even wearing a San Francisco Giants cap, which is unusual. It’s still a lovely card to have, and because there are less centering and chipping flaws than usual, his 1961 Topps card is relatively easier to locate in better grades than most other cards from the era.

1962 Topps300

The Topps set from 1962 Due to the notable centering and chipping flaws present in this iconic series with wood grain borders, it might be difficult to find a high-grade Willie Mays card. Mays was back to his happy self on this card, which has a fantastic photograph of him holding the bat out in a sort of half swing, courtesy of Topps.

1963 Fleer5

Collectors of antique baseball cards of Willie Mays were fortunate in that he was one of the stars who did not get left out of the limited-edition, 67-card set. Mays is kneeling and supporting himself with his bat, and Fleer chose a wonderful shot of him to use on their baseball cards.

1963 Topps300

In addition to having a distinctive style, the 1963 Topps baseball card collection also has a lot of cards that are quite easy to look at. The Willie Mays issue was no less aesthetically stunning than the previous one. Mays is seen raising the bat over his shoulder in a large, vivid photo that dominates the top half of the card. A tiny action photo of him swinging the bat is shown in the lower right corner of the card, which helps to complete this outstanding design.

1964 Topps150

However, even if the image that Topps chose to use for their 1964 Willie Mays baseball card is not that appealing, the overall coloring of the card truly helps it stand out. Mays is seen glancing over his right shoulder, as though he is perplexed or preoccupied in his thoughts. However, the yellow-brown colour of the Giants team name at the top of the card, as well as the border down the bottom, distinguishes it from the others. Because centering and chipping concerns were not widespread with this set, locating a high-grade copy of Willie Mays’ card may be quite simple when compared to other years in the series.

1965 Topps250

Topps from 1965 Willie Mays cards are frequently plagued by centering difficulties, and occasionally you’ll notice print bubbles in the purple-colored borders that surround the image.

The 1965 Topps issue isn’t his most costly to collect, but once again, centering concerns can prevent most of these cards from receiving higher grades than they otherwise would.

1966 Topps1

In 1966, Topps released a design that was both visually appealing and simple. The aesthetic attractiveness of this card is enhanced by a huge, vibrant color photograph of Mays tossing the ball into his own mitt. The Giants’ team name in yellow letters over a diagonal green banner across the top of the card, as well as a similar color scheme for his name down the bottom, help to distinguish it from the rest.

1967 Topps200

The 1967 Topps baseball card collection is highlighted by the rookie cards of Tom Seaver and Rod Carew, but the Willie Mays issue is still a collector favorite because to the presence of the late Willie Mays. Overall, the design is rather plain, but the enormous player portraits of Mays and others helped to make this set extremely popular among collectors and enthusiasts.

1968 Topps50

There isn’t much in the middle when it comes to the 1968 Topps baseball card design; either you adore it or you despise it. The borders, which are a fairly boring burlap color pattern, are the source of the problem. While the Nolan Ryan and Johnny Bench rookie cards from this collection are the most sought for, Mays’ card is not far behind in terms of popularity. Because of the burlap color of the borders, weathering and chipping are noticeably less obvious than they would otherwise be. Because centering concerns were less prevalent this year, locating high-quality Mays samples should be rather simple.

1969 Topps190

Is there anything about this Willie Mays baseball card that you recognize? This image is the identical one that Topps used in their 1966 issue, but it has been zoomed in even more. When it came to Willie Mays baseball cards, Topps went back to its old practices, using multiple images of the player on each card. Although it is still a fantastic card, centering can be a difficulty with this card owing to the well-known “tilt” issues that plagued the 1969 Topps series.

1970 Topps600

It’s hard to say that the 1970 Topps baseball card design is particularly memorable, thanks to its all-gray borders and subdued team, player name, and position information on the outside borders. Despite this, the Willie Mays card included in this collection retains a high level of visual appeal. In the 1970 season, Mays would hit more than 20 home runs for the final time in his career.

1971 Topps600

On the cover of his 1971 Topps issue, Mays appears to be troubled or deep in meditation. However, because of the widespread chipping concerns that have come from this design, locating high-grade Mays cards in this set has proven to be quite challenging.

1972 Topps49

During the 1972 season, Mays played for the San Francisco Giants (19 games) and the New York Mets (69 games), splitting his time between the two teams. Mays was depicted with the bat hoisted over his right shoulder on the iconic 1972 Toppsbaseball card design, which also had the words “Giants” written over the top in large, beaming letters. Although it is not one of Mays’ most popular antique baseball cards among collectors, its design is absolutely one-of-a-kind in the industry.

See also:  What Is Iso In Baseball

1973 Topps305

Willie Mays would appear on a mainstream baseball card for the final time on the 1973 Topps edition, marking his retirement from the game.

This was also the first mainstream card that featured him in a New York Mets uniform during his career. Mays would play just 66 games in the last season of his illustrious career, which spanned 22 years and saw him bat.211 with 24 runs scored, 6 home runs, and 25 RBI in 66 games.

Willie Mays Baseball Cards Wrap-up

Willie Mays is widely considered to be the greatest baseball player of all time. And he could compete with the best of them in terms of hit, run, field, and throw. As a result, his cards will continue to be very collectable for many years to come. The downside is that they’ll cost you a lot of money to put together in good quality. Even though Willie Mays’ baseball cards are not as precious as Mickey Mantle’s cards, they are still among the most desirable in the hobby, and his cards are among the best-looking.

Ross Uitts

The founder of Old Sports Cards, Ross has been collecting sports cards for over 30 years and is the driving force behind the company. He also enjoys writing about the hobby, and has contributed to publications including as Beckett, Topps, SABR, and, of course, this website. Do you need assistance in purchasing or selling cards, or do you have a general question regarding the hobby? You may reach him at

Willie Mays Baseball Cards: The Definitive Guide

Willie Mays was considered to be one of the finest five-tool players in the history of the game. At the plate, he had a rare mix of scorching speed and defensive prowess, which complimented his balance of power and precision. When it came to baseball, Willie Mays defined the way the game should be played, and his early childish enthusiasm for the sport won him the nickname “The Say Hey Kid.” Despite his on-field prowess, Mays was subjected to unrelenting bigotry, and he had an unusual relationship with the media and fans alike.

Throughout this article, we’ll look at some of the most important and valuable Wille Mays baseball cards, the majority of which are still highly sought for by collectors of vintage sports cards today.

The Say Hey Kid – Is He Underrated?

When it came to baseball, Willie Mays was the player that everyone aspired to be. Even children attempted to imitate his manner from an early age. Mays was a calm and collected individual both on and off the field. Mays’ moniker, the ‘Say Hey Kid,’ was a fitting one for him, even though the reason for his selection was unknown to the majority of baseball fans. According to sportswriter Barney Kremenko, in Mays’ first season, the reserved Mays showed signs of maturation “Every now and then, someone would blurt out: “Say who,” “say what,” “Say where,” “Say hi,” and so on.

  1. Although Mays had a promising start to his professional career with the New York Giants in 1951, he failed to get off to a good start, managing only one hit in his first 26 at-bats.
  2. The Giants won the World Series against the Yankees after 274 hits, earning them the Rookie of the Year title and advancing them to the World Series.
  3. With a.302 batting average and 660 home runs, he won two MVP titles and twelve gold glove trophies during his career.
  4. As a result of his service in the Korean War, Mays was absent from baseball for nearly two years (a significant portion of 1952 and the whole 1953 season).
  5. Despite the fact that this story by Rob Neyer at ESPNtheorizes that the potential park harm has been overstated by many people.
  6. He has, without a doubt, been the most adventurous.
  7. Willie didn’t even consider it; he’d simply go ahead and do it.
  8. Unfortunately, Mays never had the opportunity to manage a major league baseball team.
  9. Induction Speech for Willie Mays into the Baseball Hall of Fame “This country is made up of a diverse range of elements.

Baseball was my sport of choice, and I enjoyed every minute of it. I’ll limit myself to one word: love. It demonstrates commitment. Baseball necessitates a great deal of sacrifice on your part.” resources that are recommended for Willie Mays

Willie Mays Baseball Cards

In particular, the 1951 Bowman set is one of my faves – the stunning creative renditions make it one of the most attractive sets produced in the early 1950s, in my opinion. The Mays rookie card is widely regarded as the definitive representation of the player. We included the Bowman 1951 Mays as one of the holdings in our ‘All Vintage Value Portfolio’ because we believe that the card continues to be underrated in the market today. One of Bowman’s finest sets, manufactured in 1951. Willie Mays is shown in this photograph.

Typically, a decent (PSA 2) condition copy may be purchased at auction for between $1500 and $2000, however mid grade versions starting at Excellent (PSA 5) and upwards will easily exceed the $5000 mark.

1952 Berk Ross – Willie Mays39

If the 1951 Bowman Willie Mays rookie card is the belle of the ball, the 1952 Berk Ross Willie Mays baseball card might be said to be the beast. The Berk Ross set was most likely an unauthorised release, however we still consider it to be an underappreciated release. However, whereas the Bowman set was adorned with exquisite artwork, the Berk Ross set is rudimentary, with unclear photographs of the participants. Nonetheless, the Mays card, like the rest of the collection, is difficult to come by.

Despite the fact that PSA has only rated about 220 copies, collectors may still find the card in good condition or better for $500 or less.

1952 Bowman – Willie Mays218

While not quite as visually appealing as his 1951 Bowman card, the 1952 Bowman Mays is still a visually appealing card in its own right. The player’s name in the black box on the front of the card was deleted in the 1952 edition, and it was replaced with a facsimile autograph on the back. Even though the card depicts a young Mays as a member of the New York Giants, he is depicted in batting position, with a cloudy blue sky in the backdrop. The card was released in 1989. Incredibly, PSA has rated about 1500 copies of the Mays ’52 Bowman, making it somewhat more uncommon than his 1951 Bowman card (which has been graded more than 1800 times by PSA).

1952 Red Man Tobacco – Willie Mays15

Without the missing bottom tab, these Red-Man Tobacco cards were hand made and are difficult to come by without the missing bottom tab. On the fronts of the cards, there are vibrantly colored backgrounds with a brief bio in a rectangular box, all of which are eye-catching. Overall, the population of these cards is very small (only approximately 200 have been graded by PSA), and they represent exceptional value when compared to other Mays cards. When you consider that an Excellent (PSA 6) copy will cost you roughly $600, I believe this is an excellent investment opportunity for vintage card investors.

Also included in our ‘All Vintage Cards Value Portfolio’ is a Ted Williams card from the collection, which we designated as one of the concerns.

1953 Topps – Willie Mays244

The 1953 Topps collection is a classic, with each card displaying a gorgeous full-size artist rendition on the reverse side. The cards have a professional appearance because to the black box overlay, which has the player’s name in white capital letters. However, while the Mickey Mantle card from the set receives the majority of attention, the Mays ’53 Topps card has around half the PSA population of the Mantle card. Due to the fact that the Mays card has a large number of issues, the high numbers (221 to 280) were short produced in comparison to the other low number issues in the set, which explains this.

1954 Bowman – Willie Mays89

In my opinion, this Willie Mays baseball card is one of the least appealing Bowman issues ever released. Although it still depicts Willie as a member of the New York Giants, this card features players in a grainy photograph rather than the beautiful artistic renderings found on the Bowman sets from 1951 and 1952, this card is still worth collecting. Also, keep in mind that Mays was kept out of the 1953 Bowman collection since he was under contract with Topps at the time. Because PSA has graded over 2300 copies of the card, it is pretty easy to locate.

A link to 1954 Bowman Mays eBay listings – PSA 2 to PSA 5 graded cards available for less than $350 has been put together by us.

1954 Topps – Willie Mays90

The Topps 1953 collection is the third major release from the company, and while it does not have the same level of popularity as the 1952 and 1953 sets, it is still a highly popular set among vintage card collectors. The fact that the card has a large population (PSA has graded over 3300 copies) also means that it is reasonably priced. For example, although Mint copies are valued close to $20K, an Excellent copy may be had for less than $400 and a Good (PSA 2) copy for less than $100, as seen in the table below.

1955 Bowman – Willie Mays184

It was an experimental concept for Bowman, incorporating player photographs in the centre of a television set, which debuted in 1955. Some people do not like the design, but I personally think it is excellent—in fact, I think it is a milestone design, considering that cabinet televisions are now a thing of the past. This Bowman issue also has a smaller population than many of the Topps issues from the same time period. In addition, the quality of the piece is important since the brown borders are readily chipped and discolored.

List of 1955 Bowman Willie Mays graded cards that are now available on eBay for less than $350 each.

1955 Topps – Willie Mays194

The 1955 Topps cards used the identical portrait photo as the 1954 Topps set, but they were printed in a horizontal format instead of the vertical format of the previous set. It should be noted that the Bowman issue from 1955 marked the beginning of the publication’s transition to a horizontal format. Compared to other of the more popular cards from the set, this Mays card has a smaller population than some of the others. Similarly scarce, to some extent, are ares 151-160, implying that players such as Mays, Berra, or Snider are frequently more difficult to come by than players like as Williams, Robinson, or Aaron.

Here’s a list of 1955 Topps Willie Mays graded cards that are now available on eBay for less than $350 each.

1956 Topps – Willie Mays130

The 1956 Topps set continued to use the horizontal format, while Topps continued to use the same identical portrait as the previous year! This was the third set in a row in which Topps used the identical portrait image, while the smaller action shot on each card differed from the previous two. This also indicated that Topps was ramping up production, as seen by the higher PSA population for the 1956 Topps Mays issue, which was over 5000 compared to 2700 for the 1955 Topps Mays issue. It should be noted that there are two different issues of the 1956 Topps set: one with a gray back and one with a white back.

  • For some reason, the ‘white back’ card does not appear to command a significant premium over the rest of the deck.
  • Here’s a list of 1956 Topps Mays graded issues that are currently selling on eBay for less than $150.
  • Willie Mays is a baseball player who plays in the Major Leagues.
  • Despite the fact that Mays was employed as a greeter at the casino, his association with a gambling establishment irritated Major League Baseball, which resulted in his ban from the league.

1957 Topps – Willie Mays10

The 1957 Topps set saw the return of a vertical design to the Topps series, and it is one of my favorite designs from the Topps sets of the 1950s. Simply said, a full-sized player photo with white borders and offsetting white and yellow writing for the player and team names is all that’s needed to convey the message. The 1957 Topps Mays baseball card has been graded by PSA more than 4000 times. As was the case with many of the Topps issues that came before it, it’s rather simple to locate a lower grade copy for less than $100.

See also:  How To Sell Old Baseball Cards

1958 Topps – Willie Mays5

Mays’ first Topps card came out in 1958, and it depicted him as a member of the newly relocated San Francisco Giants. The cards are visually appealing, and Mays’ card portrays the ‘Say Hey Kid’ with his typical smile, despite claims that the move from New York to San Francisco was a difficult one for Mays. The 1958 Topps Mays baseball card has been graded by PSA more than 3500 times. As was the case with many of the Topps issues that came before it, it’s rather simple to locate a lower grade copy for less than $100.

1959 Topps – Willie Mays50

Though the players are surrounded by one brilliant backdrop color, the 1959 Topps baseball cards have a look and feel that is comparable to that of the 1958 edition. In my opinion, one of the more aesthetically displeasing Topps baseball card sets from the 1950s.

PSA has graded approximately 4000 copies of the 1959 Mays card, which is a similar number to the 1958 Topps set, and as a result, the pricing between the two years is largely the same for the most part. Because of this, poorer graded copies may be purchased for less than $100.

1960 Topps – Willie Mays200

The 1960 Topps baseball cards had a more comic book vibe to them, and I enjoy the appearance of these cards, which also returned to the horizontal style that had been last seen in the 1956 Topps issue, which I found to be quite appealing. The Topps Mays card from 1960 has been graded by PSA more than 4000 times. The card appears to be more popular than many of the Topps issues from the late 1950s that came before it. Higher grade copies tend to sell for more money than some of the population-based problems that are equivalent in price.

What Is The Most Valuable Willie Mays Card?

The Willie Mays261 card from the 1952 Topps set is his most valued card. Despite the fact that it is not his rookie card (that distinction belongs to his 1951 Bowman card), the 1952 Topps Mays issue remains one of the most valuable in the hobby (and expensive). Because the 1952 Topps collection is the company’s first complete release, it is extremely valuable to any antique baseball card collector. Collectors can occasionally acquire lower-grade 1952 Topps Mays cards for less than $5K; but, higher-grade versions can be rather pricey for serious investors.

All Vintage Cards

Old baseball, basketball, hockey, and football cards are the focus of All Vintage Cards’ online store, which is the most comprehensive resource for all things vintage. Our passion for card collecting, and in especially for vintage sports cards, motivates us to spread the word about the pleasures of card collecting to others.

Willie Mays Baseball Trading Cards for sale

  • T206 Honus Wagner Cover MINT from the Beckett Vintage Collector Guide for December 2019. 4.7 stars out of 5 for this product Rated 40 times for a $8.50 new purchase. Used 1997 Topps Complete Baseball Set, Series 12 Factory Sealed for $5.00 495 cards with nine inserts 5 stars out of 5 for this product. Ratings totaled 4, with a price tag of $125.00. $135.00 New
  • 2012 Topps Baseball Factory Set with Willie Mays Chrome Card5 Rookie Variations
  • $85.00 Used
  • 5 stars out of 5 for this product. 1.0 out of 5 stars New
  • Topps 2021 Baseball Series 1 BLISTER Hanger 3 Cellos Green
  • 1.0 out of 5 stars Pete Alonso is a Formula One driver who competes in the United States. 205 out of 5 stars for this product Total Reviews 1,$13.99 New
  • Factory Direct 2020 Topps Gallery Blaster Boxes and 5 Cellos are included in the price. 3 stars out of 5 for this product. 1.2019 Topps Gallery Baseball Card Pack.$6.95 new
  • 1991 Topps Archives The Ultimate 1953 Set Baseball Picture Cards. Total Ratings: 1.00 5 stars out of 5 for this product. Total Ratings 2,$49.95 New
  • 1989 Bowman Baseball Rack Packs – 5 Count Factory
  • Total Ratings 2,$49.95 New
  • Total Ratings 2 Packs of cards include 38 cards. 5 stars out of 5 for this product. a total of 1 ratings, $14.99 new $6.98 Previously owned

All Listings

  • The most appropriate match
  • Time: the earliest possible conclusion
  • Time: it has just recently been listed
  • Price + shipping is ordered from lowest to highest
  • Price + shipping is ordered from lowest to highest
  • Distance is prioritized as follows: closest first

28,779 Results

  • Baseballfilter has been applied
  • Willie Maysfilter has been applied to the player/athlete.
  • Rookie
  • Serial numbered
  • Insert
  • Patch
  • Short print
  • Parallel/variety
  • Rookie

NEW Feb/Mar 2022 Beckett VINTAGE COLLECTORPrice Guide with PETE MARAVICH

  • 4.5 stars out of 5 for this product 40 product ratings -NEW for February and March 2022 PETE MARAVICH, Beckett VINTAGE COLLECTOR, has compiled a price guide for vintage collectors. $9.95$22.28 shipping & handling SPONSORED
  • 59 units sold

Over 100 Assorted 1984 Mother’s Cookies Giants Mint Willie Mays McCovey Marichal

  • $29.99 plus delivery ($18.69) 95 sold
  • Or Best Offer95 sold

1967 Topps Baseball – Pick A Card – Cards 401-609

  • Bids totaling $202.5019 Shipping is $25.94. Ending today at 7:37 p.m. PST3 minutes and 51 seconds

2021 Topps Heritage WILLIE MAYS Box Topper Jumbo San Francisco Giants oversized

  • Bids totaling $202.5019 Shipping costs $25.94. Expiring today at 7:37 PM PST, 3 minutes and 51 seconds.

1991 Topps Archives 1953 Topps Baseball Factory Sealed Box 36 Packs

  • Bids totaling $5.092 Shipping is $41.19 per order. Ending on February 24 @ 7:00 p.m. PST4 days and 23 hours


  • Bids totaling $12.5011 Shipping is $24.60. Ending today at 7:41 p.m. PST, 8 minutes and 35 seconds


  • Bids totaling $12.5011 Shipping costs $24.60. Today, at 7:41 p.m. PST, 8 minutes and 35 seconds


  • Bids totaling $153.5018 Shipping is $25.01 per order. Ending today at 7:55 p.m. PST22 minutes and 34 seconds

1968 Topps Game Insert8 Willie Mays – VGEX – Giants

  • Bids totaling $10.507 Shipping is $23.79 USD. Ending today at 7:35 p.m. PST2 minutes and 18 seconds

1973 Topps305 Willie Mays New York MetsNo Reserve

  • Bids totaling $2.950 Shipping is $25.98. Ending on February 23 at 7:09 p.m. Pacific Standard Time3d 23h

1964 Topps Baseball – Pick A Card – Cards 201-400

  • $28,999.00$39.99 shipping and handling or the highest and best offer There is just one remaining
  • It is SPONSORED.

1959 Topps Baseball – Pick A Card – Cards 1-320

  • Shipment is $39.99. $28,999.00$39.99 or the highest and best bid SPONSORED
  • Only 1 remaining
  • Only 1 left

1965 Baseball Old London HALL OF FAMER WILLIE MAYS – San Francisco Giants

  • $28,999.00$39.99 shipping & handling or the highest bidder There is just one remaining, and it is SPONSORED.

1972 Topps50 WILLIE MAYS In Action San Francisco Giants EXMT miscut *NV15A

  • Bid of $2.951 Ends at 8:22 p.m. PST on February 21st2d
  • $12.95 shipping

1962 Topps277 4th Checklist Mays Ford Yankees Centered Sharp No Crease MINT

  • Bids in the amount of $10.000 Shipping is $22.27. Ending on February 25 at 4:52 a.m. PST5 days and 9 hours Purchase It Right Away

2022 Topps Series 1 Willie Mays Legend Image Variation103 Giants SSP

  • Bids totaling $41.0012 Shipping is $21.16. Ending on February 22nd at 7:09 p.m. Pacific Standard Time2d 23h

1963 Fleer5 Willie Mays San Francisco Giants PSA AUTH Graded Baseball Card MLB

  • Offers totaling $26.002 Shipping is $20.37. Ending on February 24 @ 6:45 p.m. PST4 days and 23 hours


  • Bids totaling $26.002 Shipping costs $20.37. It will end on February 24th at 6:45 PM PST4 days and 23 hours.

1952 RED MAN TOBACCO Willie Mays No Tab w/ Creases and Pencil Mark FAIR

  • Bids totaling $149.500 Shipping is $27.93. Ending on February 25th @ 3:17 p.m. PST5 days and 19 hours Purchase It Right Away


  • Bids totaling $3.504 Shipping is $23.30. Ending on February 22nd @ 5:09 p.m. PST2d 21 hours


  • Bid of $0.991 Shipping is $24.95 per order. Ending on February 20 at 10:20 a.m. PST14:47 a.m.

1955 bowman willie mays SGC 2

  • Bids totaling $81.0011 Shipping is $25.67. Ending on February 20th at 6:38 p.m. Pacific Standard Time (23h 5m)

Willie Mays New York Mets 1/5ACEO Fine Art Print Card By:Q

  • Bids totaling $9.990 Shipping is $17.40. Ending on February 23 @ 9:47 a.m. PST3d 14 hours

1936 Detroit Tigers Hillerichbradsby Baseball Bat Order Invoice

  • Bids totaling $37.006 Ending on February 22nd at 8:19 p.m. PST3d
  • $27.28 shipping

1964 Topps,150, HOF Willie Mays, SGC 4.5 VG-EX+, CENTERED BEAUTY!

  • Bids received for $37.006 Ends at 8:19 p.m. PST on February 22nd3d
  • $27.28 shipping

1958 Topps5 Willie Mays San Francisco Giants HOF SGC 2 Good

  • Bids totaling $23.519 Shipping is $32.00. Ending on February 23rd at 8:08 p.m. PST4d


  • Bids totaling $43.0015 Shipping is $21.15 per order. Ending on February 21 at 5:58 p.m. PST1 day and 22 hours

1965 Topps Baseball – Pick A Card – Cards 1-200

  • Bids totaling $9.614 Shipping is $25.00. Ending on February 20th at 6:59 p.m. Pacific Standard Time (23h 25m)

1996 Topps 1964 Retro Willie Mays HOF Signed AUTO San Francisco Giants

  • Bids totaling $152.5011 Shipping is $32.00. Ending on February 24 at 8:00 p.m. PST5.

1975 Topps Mini Baseball – Pick A Card – Cards 1-360

  • $0.251 per bid$21.43 per shipment Ending on February 20 at 3:18 p.m. PST19h 45 minutes

1969 Topps,190, HOF Willie Mays, SGC 6 EX-MT, CENTERED RAZOR SHARP BEUATY!

  • Bids totaled $203.5041 dollars. Shipping is $25.46. Ending on February 20th @ 6:10 p.m. PST (22h 37m)


  • Bids totaling $203.5041 Shipping costs $25.46. This offer will expire on February 20th at 6:10 p.m. Pacific Standard Time (22h 37 minutes).


  • Bids totaling $17.009 Shipping is $26.46. Ending today at 7:57 p.m. PST (24 minutes and 44 seconds)

Results Pagination – Page 1

You may also be interested in You Might Also Enjoy This Slideshow

  • The Topps Sports Trading Card Company, Panini Sports Trading Cards, Ultra PRO Sports Trading Card To, Plastic Sports Trading Cards, Sports Trading Card Toploaders, Ultra PRO Sports Trading Card Sl, BCW Sports Trading Card Toploade, Ultra PRO Sports Trading Card St, Printing Plate Sports Trading Cards, and the Ultra PRO Sports Trading Card Sl are all examples of sports trading card companies.

Top 10 Willie Mays Baseball Cards

Despite his age, Willie Mays is still considered to be one of baseball’s most cherished legends. It should come as no surprise that Willie Mays cards continue to generate significant interest, especially among collectors who may not have had the opportunity to witness him play. In a career spanning early vintage cards to high-end current successes, Mays has established himself as one of the hobby’s top-tier stars capable of anchoring a release. When it comes to all-around players, one might make a compelling argument for Mays to be the greatest in the league.

  • Mays, a first-ballot Hall of Fame inductee, concluded his career with 660 home runs, which put him in the top five all-time in the major leagues.
  • Mays has been out of the game for many decades, but he continues to appear in new sets.
  • On eBay, you may get cards of Willie Mays that have been professionally graded.
  • Although the consideration of value is important, it is not the only criterion.
  • If you’re wanting to start a Mays collection, any of these pieces may form the foundation of your collection.

View our comprehensiveWillie Mays card chronology for a more in-depth look at the many vintage possibilities available. To shop for cards on eBay, simply click on the listings or photos below. Product profiles can be accessed directly from linked sets in the descriptions.

10. 1959 Topps Willie Mays464 Baseball Thrills – Mays’ Catch Makes Series History

Although it is not one of the most valuable Willie Mays cards in existence, the 1959 Topps “Baseball Thrills” card depicts one of the most famous plays in the history of the game. This piece recreates the drama known simply as “The Catch” through the use of a storyboard-like trio of panels. The spectacular over-the-shoulder grab occurred late in Game 1 of the 1954 World Series, preserving a tie game that Mays’ Giants would go on to win in the next game.

9. 1995 Upper Deck Autograph Willie MaysAC2

The Upper Deck from 1995 The Willie Mays Autograph isn’t the most valuable of the Hall of Famer’s signature cards, but it is the first one to be made available in packs of cards (sort of). The card, which was included as part of a redemption program in 1995 Upper Deck Series 2 packs, is actually quite a good deal. The design is reminiscent of the Upper Deck base set from 1995. The back of the card has a security hologram for added protection. Mays has also worked on a number of other projects throughout the years.

See also:  How To Choose A Baseball Bat

8. 1999 Upper Deck A Piece of History 500 Club Game-Used Bat (SPx)

In addition to being a multi-year, multi-brand collection, Upper Deck’s A Piece of History 500 Club set is considered to be one of the finest and most beloved insert sets of all time. While game-used cards aren’t as exciting as they once were, 500 Club cards continue to fetch high prices anytime the opportunity arises to purchase one. The Mays card was discovered in the 1999 SPx set. There are around 350 copies of the card in existence, according to estimates. There are an additional 24 that come with an autograph.

7. 1952 Berk Ross Willie Mays7

The 1952 Berk RossWillie Mays card, which has been overlooked by many because to the success of the 1952 Topps Baseball set, could be considered something of a bargain for those searching for early cards of the outfielder. In addition to a coloured portrait and an uninteresting design, the card is 2″ by 3″ in size. This is without a doubt a part in the comparatively inexpensive pricing, especially when contrasted to the considerably more costly Topps and Bowman cards published the same year that are available for purchase.

6. 1955 Topps Willie Mays194

If one were to describe the beauty of 1955 Topps Baseball, there would be no dearth of words to choose from. The only significant difference between this year’s release and last year’s release is that the format has been switched from vertical to horizontal. This is doubly true in the case of Mays, as the film makes use of the same portrait shot. Nonetheless, it has a sophisticated appearance that continues to appeal to collectors today.

5. 1954 Topps Willie Mays90

Are you taking a second look? That’s the identical portrait that appeared on the Willie Mays Topps card from 1955. Also included is a 1956 Topps Willie Mays card. Despite the familiar appearance, this is still a card from the first week of May. The 1954 Topps design, like many other Topps sets from the era, has earned legendary status among collectors, making it easily recognized.

4. 1952 Bowman Willie Mays218

A second-year card from one of baseball’s all-time great players. And it’s magnificent — in a masculine, baseball-card kind of way, to put it another way.

The young appearance, classic attitude, and clear blue sky evoke memories of a bygone era. Despite the fact that it is not as well-known as the following card on the list, many people will agree that the 1952 Bowman is a good card. Willie Mays is the most attractive of the two players.

3. 1953 Topps Willie Mays244

Another uncharacteristically solemn photograph, this one from the 1953 Topps set. Willie Mays reaps the advantages of being a part of the late-season surge in production. Even in that case, the legend is a brief print in a series that is already in low supply. The combination of its scarcity and the fact that it is a very early Willie Mays card ensures that it will live on in the hobby for a long time.

2. 1952 Topps Willie Mays261

The1952 ToppsWillie Mays isn’t the most visually appealing of his cards. This second-year card, on the other hand, comes from a very historic release. As a result, it’s easy to overlook the fact that the all-time great doesn’t appear to be as cheerful as he usually is (at least on cardboard).

1. 1951 Bowman Willie Mays RC305

It is not only the only Willie Mays rookie card, but it is also one of the most visually appealing. The fact that the edge of the backdrop drape can be seen may appear unusual at first, but it lends a little quirk to an otherwise outstanding likeness. The 1951 Bowman Baseball set is one of the greatest ever manufactured, not just because of its checklist, but also because of its aesthetic appeal.

Special Mention:

Topps from 1956 Is it possible to include a Hank Aaron card on a list of the top Willie Mays cards? Yup. Pay attention to the person in the white jersey in the background — his face, not his jersey — and you’ll see what I mean. Say, hey, that’s Willie Mays, right there! This isn’t strictly a Willie Mays card, but it’s close enough to be considered one in certain ways. In any case, even if we are bending the truth a little, it is still an occasion to enjoy one of the most visually appealing baseball cards ever created.

Willie Mays Baseball Card – Value, Top Cards, and Checklist – Gold Card Auctions

A former center fielder for the New York/San Francisco Giants, Willie Mays was a highly renowned player who spent the most of his professional career with the team. In addition to being a 24-time All-Star, Mays was the winner of two National League MVP awards and the winner of the 1954 World Series. Willie Mays’ rookie season statistics are as follows: 121 games |.274 batting average | 20 home runs | 7 stolen bases | 68 RBIs Willie Mays is regarded as a legend in the sport, and his cards are among the most valuable in the hobby.

The Best Willie Mays Baseball Cards

We’ve scoured recent auction data to compile a list of three of the absolute bestWillie Mays baseball cards available for purchase.

1952 Willie Mays Topps261

Mays’ card, which was released as part of the legendary 1952 Topps collection that helped to revolutionize the pastime, is one of the more difficult to come by. Cards from the “semi-high” series, which debuted with the fifth 1952 Topps set (251-310), are more scarce than those from the previous series, while they are still more numerous than stars such as Mickey Mantle. Trending:Best Rookie Cards for Fernando Tatis, Jr. Due to the fact that it is almost half a century old, cards will often have poor centering, which will reduce the overall grade to a certain level.

Although it is not his official rookie card (which was released a year earlier), it is his first Topps option, making it a highly sought-after item among collectors.

1954 Willie Mays Bowman89

This Bowman card, which was released a few seasons later in 1954, depicts Mays winning a World Series ring after returning to the Giants after a brief hiatus. In 1954, he was awarded the National League MVP award, as well as the Hickok Belt, which increased his overall worth. Best Ted Williams Baseball Cards, according to our experts With a baseball bat in hand, Mays smiles for a photograph for the 1954 Bowman card, which has become an iconic picture of the player. He sheds his gruff demeanor with a smile as he poses for the photograph.

1956 Willie Mays Topps130

This Bowman card, which was released a few seasons later in 1954, depicts Mays winning a World Series ring after returning to the Giants following a brief stint in the majors. Adding to his already-impressive resume, he earned the National League MVP award and the Hickok Belt in 1954. Ted Williams Baseball Cards are our top choice. With a baseball bat in hand, Mays stands for a photograph for the 1954 Bowman card, which has become an iconic picture of the player. He sheds his gruff character as he poses for a photograph with the bat.

Most Valuable Willie Mays Baseball Card

The 1952 Topps Willie RC261 baseball card is the most expensive Willie Mays baseball card, followed by the 1951 Bowman RC305. The value ofWillie Mays baseball cards is fairly priced, and it is expected to climb steadily year after year in the foreseeable future, with no significant spikes (either up or down) in either direction. Contact us at [email protected] or send us a message on the Gold Card Auctions TwitterPage if you are thinking about purchasing a Willie Mays baseball card and would want some advise before you do so.

Willie Mays Baseball Card Checklist

We’ve compiled a comprehensive list of all of the Willie Mays baseball cards that have been released over the past 50 years. From the very first Bowman and Topps releases through the Heritage editions released in the 2000s, here is the whole list:

  • Willie Mays’ first professional baseball card was issued in 1951, and his second was issued in 1952. Willie Mays’ second professional baseball card was issued in 1953, and his third was issued in 1954. Several Willie Mays cards were released in 1959, including the Bazooka Willie Mays15, the 1959 Topps Willie Mays317, the 1959 Topps Willie Mays464 (in which Mays’ catch is recorded in series history), the 1959 Topps Willie Mays50, and the 1959 Topps563 (All-Star) 1961 Post Cereal – Hand Cut / Boxed
  • 1960 Bazooka Willie Mays13
  • 1960 Topps Willie Mays200
  • 1960 Topps Tattoos Willie Mays34
  • 1960 Topps Willie Mays564 (All-Star)
  • 1960 Topps Willie Mays7 (MasterMentor)
  • 1960 Topps Tattoos Willie Mays93 (Autographed Ball)
  • 1960 MacGregor Sporting Goods
  • 1960 Bazook 1962 Topps Willie Mays18 (Managers’ Dream)
  • 1962 Topps Willie Mays300
  • 1962 Bazooka Willie Mays38
  • 1962 Topps Willie Mays395 (All-Star Card)
  • 1962 Topps Willie Mays54 (1961 NL Home Run Leaders)
  • 1963 Bazooka Willie Mays12
  • 1963 Toy Willie Mays12
  • 1963 Topps Willi Willie Mays #1, 1966 Bazooka Willie Mays # 16, 1966 Topps Willie Mays 215 (National League 1965 Batting Leaders), 1966 Topps Willie Mays 217 (National League 1965 Home Run Leaders), 1966 Topps Willie Mays 219 (National League 1965 RBI Leaders), 1967 Bazooka Mays # 16, 1967 Topps Willie Mays 191 (Checklist Card), 1967 Topps Willie Mays 200 Willie Mays600
  • 1972 Topps49
  • 1972 O-Pee-Chee49
  • 1972 Topps50
  • 1972 O-Pee-Chee50
  • 1972 O-Pee-Chee50 1972 Kellogg’s54
  • 1973 Topps Candy Lids
  • 1972 Kellogg’s54
  • The 1977 TCMA Renata Galasso (1977-1984, Galasso Greats)245 and the 1977 TCMA Renata Galasso (1977-1984, Galasso Greats)8
  • The 1980 Laughlin 300/400/50010
  • The 1981 TCMA 1962 San Francisco Giants8
  • The 1982 Cracker Jack13
  • The 1982 TCMA Greatest Sluggers43 and the 1982 TCMA Greatest Hitters6
  • The 1982 Kmar Woolworth was founded in 1985. The following cards: Willie Mays26, 1986 Topps403 (Turn Back the Clock), and 1986 Sportflics Rookies Willie Mays, 46, is one of the Sportflics Decade Greats from 1986. Willie Mays50, Willie Mays131, 1987 Kmart Baseball’s Stars of the Decades8, 1987 Hygrade Baseball’s All-Time Greats, 1988 O’ConnellSon Ink Series 5 Willie Mays165, 1988 Pacific Legends24, 1988 Michael Paraskevas Willie Mays7
  • Bowman Award, 1989 Tiffany Inserts
  • Bowman Inserts
  • 1990 Score: The MVPs
  • Tiffany Inserts Willie Mays, 24, was included to the 1991 Swell Baseball Greats list. Willie Mays106
  • 1991 O’ConnellSon Ink Series 7 Willie Mays216
  • 1991 Topps Archives244
  • 1991 O’ConnellSon Ink Series 7 Willie Mays106
  • 1991 Topps Archives244 1991 Wiz Willie Mays255
  • 1992 Action Packed All-Star Gallery (24k Gold Inserts)14
  • 1992 Action Packed All-Star Gallery Series 1 Willie Mays14
  • 1992 Action Packed Promos
  • 1993 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes
  • 1994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes 1994 Uppr Deck All-Time Heroes Willie Mays17
  • 1994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes149
  • 1993 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes150
  • 1993 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes151
  • 1993 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes163
  • 1993 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes91
  • 1994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes10
  • 1994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes117
  • 1994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes150
  • 1994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes166
  • 1994 Uppr Deck Topps Heritage Flashbacks from 2004 To Be Handled With Caution – Willie MaysF5
  • 2004 Topps Chrome Willie MaysHCR-WM
  • Topps Heritage Then and Now (2004 Topps Heritage) Willie MaysTN1
  • Autographed Topps Heritage Real One Card from 2004 W.M.
  • 2004 Topps Heritage Grandstand Glory
  • 2004 Topps Heritage Clubhouse Collection Autograph
  • 2004 Topps Bazooka One-Liners
  • Willie MaysWM
  • 2004 Topps Bazooka One-Liners William MaysWM
  • 2004 Topps Heritage Clubhouse Collection William MaysWM
  • 2004 Topps World Series Highlight Autographs Series 1WS-WM
  • 2004 Topps World Series Highlights Series 1WS-WM

Willie Mays Baseball Cards: Buyers Guide and Investment Outlook

Mays’ name carries a great deal of weight among baseball card collectors, and there are a number of high-rated selections from the 1950s and 1960s to choose from. Because he is widely considered to be the best center fielder in the history of Major League Baseball, it is understandable.

Willie Mays Baseball Cards For Sale on eBay

If you’re searching for the highest possible return on your investment, it’s evident that you should hunt for cards that are more than a decade old. Few cards will equal the value of his RC from 1951 or his Topps from 1952, but other undervalued possibilities have the greatest potential to increase in value as Mays approaches his 90th year on the field of play.

How much is a signed Willie Mays baseball card worth?

When it comes to baseball cards, an autographed Willie Mays baseball card will often sell for 20 percent to 40 percent more than the basic price of the particular card.

Please contact us at [email protected] for an estimate of the worth of your gold card.

What is the most expensive Willie Mays Baseball Card?

The iconic 1952 Topps Willie Mays Baseball Card261, signed by Willie Mays, is the most expensive Willie Mays baseball card.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.