What Is Defensive Indifference In Baseball

What is Defensive Indifference in Baseball – When Does it Occur?

When one side is leading by a large number of runs in the ninth inning, a baserunner may be able to steal a base without the catcher throwing him out. Because the catcher had thrown to second base earlier in the game to prevent a prior base robber from advancing, this seems puzzling. As a result, why did the defensive team allow this play to proceed in the ninth inning without making a throw? Answering the question with defensive disinterest is the best way to put it. So, what exactly is defensive indifference, when does it come into play, how does it get recorded on a scorecard, and so on?

What is Defensive Indifference in Baseball?

When one team steals a base without the other team attempting to throw them out on the base paths, this is referred to as defensive apathy. Typically, the apathy happens in the ninth inning (or extra innings) of a baseball game when the score is not even close to being decided. The formal determination, on the other hand, is made by the official scorer, who determines whether it should be considered defensive indifference or stolen base.

When to use Defensive Indifference in a Baseball Game?

MLB clubs batting in the late innings of a game are more likely to deploy defensive indifference (fielder’s choice) to eliminate the possibility of a double play. For example, a club in the ninth inning with one out and down by five runs may elect to have their first baserunner steal second base in order to avoid a double play scenario for their batter. The defensive team may decide not to throw to second base on the next throw because they do not want to risk making a mistake and allowing the baserunner to advance to third.

In the above scenario, the run will make no difference in the outcome of the game, which is why the official scorer will not count it as a stolen base on that occasion.

It is the official scorer’s responsibility to determine the game’s circumstances, as well as the defensive team’s actions and other factors.

What’s the Difference Between Defensive Indifference and Stolen Base?

The key distinction between defensive indifference and a stolen base is the time at which it happens, as well as the fact that the run now in scoring position will have no impact on the result of the game. Typically, the defensive indifference call will be made during the ninth inning (or extra innings) of a game if the opposing team is down by a couple of runs. In contrast to defensive indifference, a stolen base can be recorded during a baseball game at virtually any moment, with the exception of the ninth inning when the game is already out of reach.

A stolen base does not occur during a wild pitch or passed ball, however, unless the baserunner was already attempting to steal that base at the time of the wild pitch or passed ball.

A stolen base can be awarded to both runners on the same play in a double steal situation if both are safe on the play. For example, if one of the runners is thrown out while attempting to steal third base, the runner attempting to take second base will not earn a stolen base credit for that base.

When Did Defensive Indifference Start in Major League Baseball?

Defensive apathy became the norm around 1920, according to The New York Times.

How Do You Score Defensive Indifference on a Scorecard?

The addition of a “DI” or “FI” to a scorecard indicates a defense or fielder’s disinterest in the game while it is being played. If a stolen base happens throughout the course of the game, you must mark it as SB and draw a line through it to indicate where the baserunner will progress to the next base. If a baserunner is thrown out due to being caught stealing, you should mark the scorecard with a line halfway between the base they were on and the base where they attempted to swipe unsuccessfully.

Is it a Stolen Base if the Catcher Doesn’t Throw?

A stolen base does not necessitate the use of a throw to the base by the catcher. However, there were situations when the base stealer’s lead off from a base and leap was so outstanding that the catcher decided not to chance the throw to first base. One of the rare situations in which a stolen base will not occur is when the batter is forced to choose between first and second base.

Can a Defensive Indifference Positively Impact the Game?

The majority of the time, a fielder’s lack of interest will have little effect on the ultimate score of the game. It isn’t a big concern if the game isn’t even close and the defense has to take a base in order to avoid a double-play opportunity. That is why some middle infielders choose to play further back in the infield in an attempt to prevent the hitter from getting a base hit rather than playing closer to second base in an attempt to prevent a stolen base. Even sports statistics websites such asBaseball Reference andBaseball Savant do not keep track of defensive disparities that occur during a game.

Conclusion – What is Defensive Indifference in Baseball

In summary, defensive indifference, also known as fielders indifference, is a judgement made by the official scorer during the course of a sporting event. It occurs during the ninth inning (or extra innings) of a baseball game if the score is overwhelming in favor of one team. For example, if a baserunner steals second base while behind by five runs in the ninth inning, it makes no difference whether or not he scores. Finally, defensive indifference is a method of limiting the use of phony statistics in baseball.

For example, a defense may use playback during an at-bat to prevent a hitter from making a base hit and advancing to the next round.

Similar Posts

In baseball, what exactly is an RBI? What is RISP in Baseball? Baseball is an acronym that stands for Risk-Induced Susceptibility to Punishment. wOBA In baseball, what exactly is the strike zone? In baseball, the World Series is known as the World Series. Baseball Sliding is a type of sliding. Baseball Batting Average for Mitts In baseball, what exactly is a PO? TOOTBLAN Baseball is a sport that is played in the United States.

In baseball, what exactly is the Triple Crown Award? MLB Trade Deadline is fast approaching. Bases are being stolen in baseball. What is the length of a baseball game? What Does the Abbreviation QAB Mean in Baseball? In baseball, what is the term “caught stealing”?

Stolen Bases, Wild Pitches, Passed Balls, and Defensive Indifference

It appears to be straightforward. You’re well aware of what a stolen base is. However, the reality is that most spectators, coaches, and scorekeepers are clueless when it comes to scoring stolen bases when other considerations are taken into consideration. Some of these considerations are as follows: As a result, scorekeepers frequently register stolen bases that are either too many or too few. I’m attempting to do a public service in this situation. The majority of scorekeepers make this mistake.

However, I am convinced that there is a straightforward method of scoring these items.

First, let’s take a closer look at some of the wild pitches and passed balls.

Definition: Wild Pitch

The following is a very basic description of a wild pitching pitcher in Major League Baseball: In baseball, a pitcher is penalized for throwing a wild pitch when his pitch is so out of control that the catcher is unable to handle it and as a result, baserunners advance. There are two important considerations:

  1. The catcher is unable to control the pitch AND at least one baserunner advances as a result of this inability to control the pitch

Although the pitch may be too wild for the catcher to manage, a wild pitch will not result in a run being scored as long as a runner does not advance on the pitch. Runners can also be players who move from first, second, or third base to first base, or batters who advance to first base as a result of a strikeout, among other things (via wild pitch or passed ball).

Definition: Passed Ball

So, what is a passed ball, and how does it work? Another example from Major League Baseball: A caught pitch occurs when the catcher fails to hang onto a pitch that, in the opinion of the official scorer, should have been caught and as a result of this, at least one runner advances to the next base. The following are the keys of a passed ball:

  1. A baserunner advances as a consequence of the catcher’s inability to control the pitch AND
  2. A baserunner advances as a result of the catcher’s SHOULD have controlled the pitch

The distinction between a wild pitch and a passed ball is negligibly small. In both instances, the catcher is unable to manage the situation, and at least one runner progresses to the next level. When a passed ball is scored in the view of the scorekeeper, it means that the catcher SHOULD have had possession of the ball. But how can we tell if a ball should have been handled by the catcher in the first place? A wild pitch is defined as any pitch that touches the soil before reaching the catcher and results in a runner moving forward.

  • Any pitch that the catcher completely misses would also be considered a wild pitch in most cases.
  • The space in between is up for interpretation.
  • Catchers should, in most cases, block pitches thrown into the dirt.
  • A wild pitch is defined as any pitch in the dirt that moves a runner forward.

As a result, not only will the greatest catchers have a low number of passed balls, but they will also avoid wild pitches from occurring. This is no different from the top first basemen, who not only make minimal errors, but also prevent other infielders from making mistakes.

Stolen Base Defined

We believe we understand what a stolen base is, but the reality is that there are circumstances where the theft of a second or third base is not as evident as the direct theft of a second or third. According to Major League Baseball, a stolen base is defined as follows: When a baserunner advances by stealing a base that he is not entitled to, this is known as stealing a base. A pitcher delivering a pitch, but it may also happen while the pitcher still has the ball or is trying a pickoff, or while the catcher is sending the ball back to the pitcher, is an example of a pitching strike.

  • During a pitch
  • When the pitcher has the ball in his or her hands During a successful pickoff attempt (with no errors)
  • While the pitcher is being thrown to by the catcher

Stolen Base or Wild Pitch/Passed Ball?

On occasion, scorekeepers will award a stolen base to a baserunner after a passed ball or wild pitch, despite the fact that the baserunner was not attempting to steal the base in the first place. You’ll also witness a base stealer being denied the opportunity to advance when the ball slips through his grasp. It goes without saying that both of these games are being scored improperly. As long as a baserunner does not make an effort to steal a base as soon as the ball crosses home plate and does not advance until the catcher is unable to control the pitch, the baserunner should not be awarded a stolen base.

Additionally, a baserunner who successfully advances to the next base while running with the pitch (or before to reaching the plate) will be awarded one base for each base successfully advanced.

It is technically possible for a stolen base to occur on the same pitch as a wild pitch or a passed ball.

A wild pitch or passed ball will also be awarded to the runner if the ball is not controlled by the catcher at the time of the steal.

Defensive Indifference Defined

You’ll frequently encounter a scoring situation where a runner advances to the next base because to defense apathy, rather than the usual stolen base, wild pitch, or passed ball. According to Baseball-Reference.com, the following is the definition: When a game is in its final stages, defensive Indifference occurs when the defending team, whether it is ahead or down by a significant margin, allows an advancing player to progress to the next base without making any attempt to force the runner out.

See also:  Who Buys Baseball Cards Near Me

However, the following are the essentials of displaying defensive indifference:

  1. A runner makes his way to another base, and the defense makes no move to get him back.

This is a definition that I despise. In addition, I believe that applying this term to Major League Baseball is less difficult than applying it to young baseball. The term also makes mention of the time and the outcome of the game, although they shouldn’t be taken into consideration. And, more specifically, what are the “latter phases” of a game?

And what exactly is a “substantial sum”? It is rarely seldom the case in young baseball when defensive indifference is scored late in the game of a blowout, as I can attest to the fact. Due to the fact that the catcher did not make a throw, it is being construed in this manner. That is incorrect.

Stolen Base or Defensive Indifference?

In my opinion, defensive disinterest is scored far too frequently in young baseball, and it should be punished severely. As an example, consider the following situation:

  1. The first baseman is keeping an eye on the runner. Pitcher hurling from the length of the mound
  2. The runner get a HUGE jump
  3. Middle infielders may or may not cover the outfield positions. The catcher does not bother to send the ball to the second baseman.

Defensive apathy is frequently assigned to the situation described above. Was the defense, on the other hand, uninterested? The first baseman was keeping the runner on the basepaths. It was clear that the pitcher was throwing from the stretch in order to keep the runner on the bases. The fact that a throw was not made is due to the fact that the runner had a large jump. You wouldn’t strip a runner of a stolen base just because he got a tremendous jump while doing precisely what he was supposed to do, would you?

Consider scoring defensive indifference when a player advances and one or more of the following events occurs:

  • In either case, the pitcher throws from the windup and does not attempt to grab the runner. In this situation, the first baseman does not retain the runner and no throw is attempted to bring the runner in.

In this case, a first baseman may be required to play behind a runner even while a pitcher is throwing from the stretch position. In that situation, I’d be perfectly happy to classify any advancement as defensive apathy. It is more difficult to detect defensive disinterest when a player advances to third. Every pitch that a middle infielder throws does not necessarily result in a runner being held at second. He may be ignored by the pitcher. I believe that the issue is whether the pitcher was pitching from the stretch or the windup when he threw the ball.

First and Third Situations

A first and third situation is one you’ll see more often at the younger level than at the upper levels. In this circumstance, the runner at first sprints to second in the hopes of drawing a throw. If a throw is made, the runner at third is given the opportunity to try to score. There are various ways to defend against this, but many of them involve not throwing to second — or at the very least having the pitcher or middle infielder cut off the throw — in the first place. Is it still considered a stolen base if the throw to second is not completed and the runner is safe?

  1. However, I’d want to go back to my first test.
  2. Was the first baseman successful in keeping the runner at bay?
  3. If the runner’s replies to both of these questions are affirmative, I would award him a stolen base.
  4. And, to be honest, when the bases are 60 or 70 feet apart, there’s rarely a cause to throw the ball.
  5. Instead, I’d use the examples in 1 and 2 above as a guide.

Keep it Simple

Keep things simple, especially when it comes to child baseball – and especially when it comes to younger ages. Running for second base after a pitch is successful, the runner should nearly always be given credit for a stolen base, regardless of whether or not the pitch was successful. There may be an exceedingly rare instance in which defensive indifference is displayed, but that should be considered to be just that – extremely unusual.

Don’t try to be cute. Never try to impress us with your understanding of this concept known as “defensive indifference” when the fact is that it is rarely seen at the juvenile level. Just award that child a stolen base and call it a day. He is deserving of it.

Your Turn

What are the best ways to score stolen bases, wild pitches, passed balls, and defensive indifference? Read on to find out. Please share your thoughts in the comments section below! (This page has been seen 20,681 times, with 5 visits today)

What is the history/reasoning behind the defensive indifference rule in MLB?

According to this 2009 article in the New York Times regarding defensive apathy, What it implies is precisely what it implies: a circumstance in which the team was indifferent about blocking the runner from moving forward. After considering the score and the inning, as well as whether or not the pitcher attempted pickoffs and whether or not the first baseman was positioned behind the runner, official scorers evaluate whether or not the sprint was a steal or a case of defensive indifference. According to Bill Shannon, who has been a scorer for 31 seasons, “It’s an ancient rule, but it’s a really excellent one.” “I’m apprehensive about disclosing statistics successes.” The question remains, however, as to what happens to the runner who has successfully scooted the 90 feet.

Should a runner be rewarded for taking advantage of a situation when the team’s defensive plan was to give up the base because it was available?

Bob Waterman, a senior baseball employee at Elias, explained that the rule book was amended in 1920 to include the provision that “no stolen base shall be awarded to a runner who is permitted to advance without an effort being made to prevent him from doing so.” It is frequently enforced in the ninth inning of a blowout game, when the defense yawns as a baserunner steals a meaningless base and the game becomes even more lopsided.

Steve Hirdt, the executive vice president of Elias, spotted references to defensive disinterest when reviewing play-by-play records of games from the 1920s, the story further states.

The regulation, according to Hirdt, is a good one since it “protects the essence of what a stolen base is.” It appears that baseball’s rulemakers had a fairly rigorous definition of what constituted a stolen base because they did not want pointless stat padding in the game.

Defensive Indifference: Baseball Terminology

A stolen base is not recognized as a stolen base when the following conditions are met. Unless the defense actively attempts to prevent the theft of a base, the play is deemed a case of defensive indifference rather than a theft of base. To steal something that has already been handed to you is a difficult task. Therefore, if the defense does not fight the steal attempt, the official scorer should not credit the baserunner with a stolen base. For players who are attempting to inflate their numbers during a game that has gotten out of hand, this may be quite discouraging.

  • Defensive Indifference is a baseball term that refers to a lack of interest on the part of the defense.
  • sizes=”(max-width: 300px) 100vw, 300px”> One unwritten rule in baseball is that if a team is ahead by a significant margin of runs, players are not expected to steal bases, try for extra base hits, or otherwise embarrass their opposition.
  • The rule of defensive indifference clearly has an impact on the number of official stolen bases.
  • When a runner like this gets to second base, most teams will not allow him to steal a bag.
  • It is possible that a disagreement will arise when a catcher fails to attempt a throw in other instances.
  • Evidently, this is not an attempt to force the thief from second base to leave the game.
  • Defensive Indifference is a baseball term that refers to a lack of interest on the part of the defense.

” data-image-caption=” ” The term “Baseball Terminology Defensive Indifference” is defined as follows: data-medium-file=” data-large-file=” loading=”lazy” ” width=”480″ height=”267″ ” width=”480″ “> The following is an example of a formalized formalized formalized Despite the fact that the catcher did not throw, this was not a case of defensive carelessness.

The batter receives credit for the home run even if the batter smashes the ball out of the park on a BP fastball that was thrown just over the plate.

In some cases, even if you witness David Ortizor or Billy Butler taking second base in the ninth inning of a baseball game, they may not have a stolen base on their record.

Unfortunately, the rule of defensive indifference applies to both slow and fast runners, and there is no distinction between the two. But it is a ruling that puts stat padders at bay for the time being.

Stolen Base (SB)

When a baserunner advances by stealing a base that he is not entitled to, this is known as stealing a base. A pitcher delivering a pitch, but it may also happen while the pitcher still has the ball or is trying a pickoff, or while the catcher is sending the ball back to the pitcher, is an example of a pitching strike. When a runner advances to a base during one of the aforementioned circumstances, the stolen base is not automatically credited; the official scorer must additionally judge that the runner was attempting to steal the base.

  1. However, if he was attempting to steal as a wild pitch or passed ball was being thrown, he is usually granted credit for the steal because of the circumstances.
  2. The fact that he made it safely to the end zone does not detract from the fact that another runner who attempted to steal on the same play was thrown out.
  3. In addition, if the defense surrender the base as a result of the current game circumstances, he will not receive credit.
  4. Stolen bases have clear advantages; the runner advances one base and brings himself closer to the goal line as a result.
  5. An individual who steals bases at a 50% clip is seen to be doing his team a harm in this context.
  6. A stolen-base attempt is one of the most strategic plays in baseball, and there are few better than it.
  7. Certain runners, however, who have shown themselves to be adept base stealers, are granted “the green light,” which allows them to leave at their own discretion.
  8. The negative consequences of theft are lessened in this situation.
  9. However, if the runner is safe, he has placed himself in a position to score.
  10. Aside from being fast, though, there are other ingredients in the stolen foundation.

In order to achieve a solid first step, he must also be able to judge the scenario and the pitcher’s pickoff movement.


When the contemporary steal rule was implemented in 1898, it was considered revolutionary. Previously, each time a runner took an additional base (for example, moving to third base from first base on a single), he was given a stolen base for that particular run.

In A Call

Slang terms for this include “swipes,” “steals,” and “stolen bags.”

Defensive Indifference or Defensive Ignorance?

In a nutshell – This season, how many times have the Dodgers allowed a runner on first base to advance to second base as a result of Defensive Indifference? Don’t know what I’m talking about? Okay, here’s something a little less difficult. How many times has a Dodgers base runner been able to score after the Dodgers used Defensive Indifference on him this season? You can’t seem to discover the answer? The reason for this is that it is a baseball statistic that no one, not even Baseball-Reference.com, the world’s most popular baseball website, maintains.


Despite the fact that neither Baseball-Reference nor anyone else tracks Defensive Indifference (which, by the way, is officially scored “DI/FC”), I can tell you with certainty that in the last week alone, two base runners that the Dodgers allowed to advance to second base on Defensive Indifference came around to score – including last night’s game against the lowly Diamondbacks (see below).

  • Dodgers closer Kenley Jansen transformed an 8-5 laugher into an 8-6 nail-biter on Tuesday night, when Padres pinch hitter Will Venable scored from second base after being called for Defensive Indifference.
  • Although it is true that a defensive infielder (DI) is only employed when the team on defense is up by a significant margin, generally five runs or more, it is also true that it is only utilized in the last inning.
  • Further, there have been instances where teams have rallied to win games after falling down by a significant margin (the Dodgers being an exception) as a result of a comeback that was sparked by (you got it) Defensive Indifference.
  • Because of their large lead, defenses are willing to give the runner second base so that they can keep their right side of the infield in a better defensive position.
  • It goes without saying that when DI is used with less than two outs, not only is the team conceding second base, but they are also conceding the possibility of a double play, which could result in the game being ended.
  • So where did Defensive Indifference originate from, or perhaps a better question is when did it begin?
  • According toSteve Hirdt, the executive vice president of Elias Sports Bureau, he noticed references to Defensive Indifference while researching play-by-play accounts of games from the 1920s.
See also:  How To Draw A Baseball Cap

The article headline read “Cut Out the Joke Steals.” In other words, quit giving guys credit for stolen bases when no attempt is made by the pitcher or first baseman to hold the runner on first base or any attempt by the catcher to throw out the runner or either middle infielder to cover the base.

The official scorer shall score such a play as a fielder’s choice.

For example, with runners on first and third bases, the official scorer should ordinarily credit a stolen base when the runner on first advances to second, if, in the scorer’s judgment, the defensive team had a legitimate strategic motive—namely, preventing the runner on third base from scoring on the throw to second base— not to contest the runner’s advance to second base.

New York Yankees outfielder/DH Carlos Beltran once admitted that he didn’t even know what Defensive Indifference was until he was well into his 17-year MLB career.

“If the first baseman plays 50 feet behind me, there’s no way that’s a steal,” Beltran said.

But once that lead drops below eight runs, all bets are off and it becomes time to “step on their throats” (and hope like hell that it isn’t too late).

I am also opposed to Defensive Indifference whenever there are fewer than two outs, opting instead to try for a back-breaking (and spirit-breaking) game-ending double play – but that’s just my take on it. What about you? What’s your take onDefensive Indifference?

In baseball what is defensive indifference?

Salvador Braun posed the question. Score: 4.8 out of 5 (41 votes) What it denotes is precisely what it implies: a circumstance in which a team was careless about blocking an opponent’s running back from advancing.

What is defensive indifference?

Indifference on the defense is a noun. This is an official scoring decision in which a stolen base is not credited because the team on the field did not make any effort to prevent the steal. (baseball) The majority of the time, this occurs late in a game when the fielding side is ahead by at least two runs.

How do you score defensive indifference?

Stolen bases are signified by the letter “SB” in baseball statistics. It is called defensive indifference (also known as fielder’s indifference) when the defense does not make any effort to throw out the baserunner (for example, if the catcher does not even look his way). The runner is not awarded a stolen base as a result of this play.

When did defensive indifference start?

It is frequently enforced in the ninth inning of a blowout game, when the defense yawns as a baserunner steals a meaningless base and the game becomes even more lopsided. According to the report, when examining play-by-play accounts of games from the 1920s, Steve Hirdt, the executive vice president of Elias, came across allusions to defensive apathy and decided to investigate more.

When can you not steal a base in baseball?

It is not possible to steal a base on a “dead” or foul ball. It is permissible to bestolen on overthrown or passed balls as long as the ball is still regarded to be “live.” It’s possible that the base ahead of you is vacant (unless the runner ahead of you also attempts to steal the base in front of them; this is known as a double steal) There were 31 questions that were connected.

Can you steal home on a walk?

It is not necessary to look back if the pitcher makes an excellent play on one of the runners. Yes, they can sneak home as long as the runner on third does not break the look back rule, which is rare.

What does R mean in baseball?

A run is awarded to a player if he crosses the plate in order to score a run for his side. When calculating the number of runs scored, the method by which a player reached base is not taken into account.

Does defensive indifference count as a stolen base?

It is a play in the final stages of a game in which the defensive side, whether ahead or behind by a significant margin, lets a player to advance to a base without making any attempt to force the runner out. A stolen base in the official box score is not awarded in the situation of defensive indifference, and the runner is not rewarded one.

Does it count as a stolen base if the catcher doesn’t throw?

If no throw is made, a stolen base or defensive indifference may be recorded as a result of the situation (DI).

What is the difference between a wild pitch and a passed ball?

Passed balls and wild pitches are similar in that they both allow a runner to move to the next base on his own without stealing one. There is one significant difference: a passed ball is considered the fault of the catcher, but a wild pitch is considered the fault of the pitcher.

What is catcher’s interference in baseball?

Catcher’s interference is a sort of interference that happens when the catcher makes contact with the batter (or his bat) during a pitch, or when the catcher in any other way hampers or impedes a hitter’s ability to hit a pitch.

How is a fielder’s choice scored?

Fielder’s choice is normally scored when the scorekeeper finds that the fielder made a throw to one of the bases with the intent of getting someone else rather than the hitter, and that the fielder had the option of retiring the batter instead.

When there is a runner on first base and a ground ball on the infield, this is a usual situation.

How do you score a stolen base?

It is technically possible for a stolen base to occur on the same pitch as a wild pitch or a passed ball. Whenever a runner takes off for second or third base and the catcher is unable to hold the ball, and the runner subsequently advances to still another base, he will receive one stolen base in addition to any bases gained as a result of a wild pitch or passed ball.

Why can a batter run on a dropped third strike?

A dropped third strike is regarded as a live ball, which means that if a runner crosses home plate before the third out is recorded, a run would be awarded to the batter. Furthermore, because the dropped third strike play would function as if it were a normal live ball, a run would not be scored if the last out of the inning is made as a result of a force out.

What is a wild pitch in baseball?

A pitcher is charged with throwing a wild pitch if his ball is so inaccurate that the catcher is unable to control it and, as a result, baserunner(s) advance on the pitch. Official scorers determine whether a pitch qualifies as a passed ball or wild pitch by calling it either one of the two things.

What is the difference between obstruction and interference in baseball?

One important distinction between interference and obstruction is the following: Interference is defined as a violation of either the attack or the defense; obstruction is defined as a violation of solely the defense’s rules of engagement.

What qualifies as a stolen base?

Stolen bases are acquired by baserunners as they make their way forward through the ranks of the game’s players. A pitcher delivering a pitch, but it may also happen while the pitcher still has the ball or is trying a pickoff, or while the catcher is sending the ball back to the pitcher, is an example of a pitching strike.

Is a balk a stolen base?

For the purposes of this rule, the stolen base was defined as “any base that is advanced by a runner without the assistance of a base hit, a putout, a forceout, a fielder’s choice, a passed ball, a wild pitch, or a balk.”

Which base is the most stolen during baseball games?

Those who hold the record Rickey Henderson holds the record for the most base stealers in Major League Baseball history, having swiped 1,406 bases during his career.

Can a runner steal on a walk?

Any runners attempting to steal on an HBP must return to their starting base unless they are compelled to move to the next base regardless. When a walk occurs, the ball remains alive: any runner who is not obliged to advance may yet attempt to advance at his or her own risk, which may occur on a stolen play, passed ball, or wild pitch, among other things.

What does TB mean in baseball?

Total bases refer to the amount of bases that a hitter has amassed as a result of his hits in a game. A single, a double, a triple, and a home run all result in one total base for the hitter, two total bases for a home run, three total bases for a triple, and four total bases for a home run.

Can you steal first base?

allowing the theft of first base to take place. The hitter has the option to sprint to first base at any moment throughout the game while the baseball is on the ground, whether it is due to a wild pitch, a passed ball, or simply because the catcher does not catch the ball cleanly.

What does G mean in baseball?

Games that have been played (G) Grand Slam is a series of victories in a single sport (GSH) Toss The Ball Into Double Play (GIDP) The Groundout-to-Airout Ratio (GO/AO) is the ratio of groundout to airout. Pitch-for-pitch (HBP)

What does the H stand for in baseball?

A hit happens when a hitter hits the baseball into fair area and does not advance to second base as a result of an error or a fielder’s choice by the defense. In the event that a player gets thrown out while attempting to advance to another base (for example, turning a single into a double), the hit is still counted as a hit. Hits come in different shapes and sizes.

Why are there 4 Strikes and 3 strikes?

As a result, in 1858, called strikes were instituted with one caveat: hitters would only receive one “warning” call for each hittable pitch that they allowed to pass before striking out. As a result, it would take four strikes to get an out in this situation. Even with the called strikes, the game moved at a snail’s pace throughout.

Baseball Heresies: When Indifference is Not Indifference

Baseball Heresies: When Indifference Isn’t Just Plain Old Indifference Dr. Joel Kupfersmid has a Ph.D. It is the opinion of the Official Rules of Baseball that a stolen base is only given if, in the opinion of the official scorer, the defense cares enough to make an effort to prevent it from taking place. “Indifference” is the phrase used to describe a defense that is disinterested about a base runner. “The official scorer shall not record a stolen base when a runner advances simply as a result of the defensive team’s indifference to the runner’s advancement,” according to the Rules.

  1. When I look at the idea of “indifference,” it doesn’t make any sense to me.
  2. Scenario number one: It’s the bottom of the ninth inning, and the defense has a three-run lead with no outs in the game.
  3. The first baseman does not tangle with him, but instead plays him back.
  4. The ball is thrown into the earth.
  5. Was the defense indifferent to Martinez in this instance, or if the catcher had made a clean catch, would he have threw the ball to second base instead?
  6. Because he is so sluggish, he is frequently left alone.
  7. Victor is not a runner in the traditional sense.
See also:  What Does Rhp Mean In Baseball

Supposing that scenario 2 occurs, the defense is up by three runs with no outs in the bottom of the ninth inning.

The first baseman does not tangle with him, but instead plays him back.

The ball is thrown into the earth.

A high likelihood exists that Bonds will not be credited with a stolen base in this instance since he was not held on by the first baseman, even if a play at second may have been made had the catcher caught the ball in a clean manner.

It’s the bottom of the ninth inning, and the defense has a three-run lead with no outs, and the game is still tied.

Joe Smith, the hitter behind him, is the one who receives the first pitch.

The pitcher receives the ball after it has been returned to him by the catcher.

The ball is once again thrown to the pitcher by the catcher.

At this point, Bonds is halfway down the third base line when the shortstop tosses the ball to first, allowing Bonds to score while also forcing Smith out of play.

First and foremost, Bonds is purposefully walked.

They do this on purpose in order to allow him to move to first base.

Unquestionably true.

Despite the fact that this plate appearance will contribute to him having a better On Base Percentage, it will not be included as an at bat in the calculation of his batting average.

Bonds moves to second base on the first pitch, then on the second pitch, he advances to third base, all without any effort on the part of the defense to block his advancement.

Joe Smith knocks a strong grounder to the shortstop on the third ball he receives.

This is just as egregious an example of defensive apathy as Bonds’ advancement to second and third place in the voting.

Rather, Bonds is credited with a run scored and Smith is credited with an RBI in the game.

The bases are loaded with two quick runners, one on first and the other on third.

Because the catcher is concerned that the runner on third base would steal home if a throw is made to second, he returns the ball to the pitcher.

Despite the fact that the catcher’s answer appears to be indifferent to the runner, the runner on first is likely to receive credit for the stolen base.

This particular provision, however, does not apply in the case of a player who advances from home to first or third to home.

Yet another example of this discrepancy is the popular practice of “throwing around” the greatest hitter in an opponent’s lineup and the eighth batter in the National League, to name a few.

No matter if the hitter swings at a terrible pitch or takes the pitches and walks to first base, the defense is unconcerned.

What makes this different from not keeping a runner on base in the instances above, when he has the option of choosing whether or not to “steal” the next base?

Given that there is no difference between getting on first base and scoring a run, why make an exemption for advancing uncontested to second or third base in a game?

With intentional walks or pitching around a batter, the defense isn’t concerned with the batter getting to first base or, in the case of a large lead in the late innings, with the runner scoring from second base.

The indifference policy demands the official scorer to read the mentality of the defense, but which defensive player is required to do this?

Is it the catcher who fails to make an attempt to throw to second or third base when the opportunity presents itself?

Alternatively, is the manager instructing his players to put out no effort?

As previously stated, I urge that the Rules eliminate the requirement for the scorer to employ psychic mind reading powers. Instead, I recommend that the concept of indifference be removed from the Rules and that players earn credit for a stolen base in these situations.

Stolen base vs defensive indifference

Brian oshea Posts:173 Posted on: Monday, February 28th, 2011 at 1:39 p.m.

Stolen base vs defensive indifference

First and third place finishers. The pitch is sent to the plate, and the runner on first attempts to steal second. Recognizing that a throw to second would allow the runner on third to score, the catcher simply sends the ball back to the pitcher, resulting in the runner on first moving up to second and the runner on third moving up to third. Is this a stolen base, or is it a defensive move out of deference? Since the defending team made no attempt to bring down the runner, I’ve always assumed it was a case of defensive disinterest on the defensive end.

According to the announcer, that was a stolen base.

OhioTexPosts:5491 Joined at 6:48 a.m.

The location is Columbus, Ohio.

Re: Stolen base vs defensive indifference

PostbyOhioTex on Thursday, July 7th, 2011 12:29 p.m. Please see the following section for MLB rules criticism (emphasis added). Yes, that is an illegally obtained base. Most leagues follow the lead of Major League Baseball, but that does not imply that it is fully relevant to all ages, all levels, and so on. It may be a matter of judgment. The trick, in my opinion, is to choose a standard and apply it consistently in your rating, while still keeping the standard age appropriate. I have not come across any equivalent clarification in quick pitch regulations that either agrees with or contradicts the notion that anything other than a stolen base should be included.

If, for example, the defensive side fails to defend the progress of a runner who is closing in on a league or lifetime record or a league statistical title, the official scorer may find that the defensive team is impermissibly attempting to deny a runner credit for a stolen base.

on Sunday, May 10, 2009.

Re: Stolen base vs defensive indifference

OhioTex posted on Thursday, July 7th, 2011 at 12:59 p.m. due to the fact that you are not scoring for the big league Don’t be concerned. You now understand, but that does not exclude you from adjusting to your newfound knowledge.

There are also more distinctions between fastpitch and baseball. If you have maintained consistency, take advantage of it and use it in the manner that best suits your needs. fmcfish Posts:15 Posted on: Saturday, August 27, 2011 7:31 p.m.

Re: Stolen base vs defensive indifference

On August 27, 2011, at 7:50 p.m., fmcfish posted a message. In my opinion, it is unjust to penalize the pitcher with a “stolen base against” when he/she did not even attempt to throw the runner out at the plate. The term “defensive indifference” is frequently used in this situation in order to provide a more accurate assessment of the catcher’s defensive statistics. bepeacock Posts:61 Joined at 6:19 a.m. on Saturday, June 11, 2011. Little Rock, Arkansas is the location of this event.

Re: Stolen base vs defensive indifference

»Sunday, August 28, 2011 7:00 p.m. by Postbybepeacock I’ve come to realize that DI should be used with caution. Typically only in the final inning when a team is batting and is significantly behind in the game, making it irrelevant whether or not the runner advances. Obviously, if he does not represent the tying or winning rung, he is disqualified. Bovine Posts:6 Joined:Thu Sep 29, 2011 7:36 am

Re: Stolen base vs defensive indifference

PostbyBovine on September 29, 2011 at 8:13 a.m. OhioTex is 100% accurate in his assessment. My most recent Level 3 Scorers Accreditation training session included a discussion of this circumstance. Having said that, it is important to note that Major League Baseball (MLB) is responsible for writing the Rules Of Baseball. It is sometimes necessary to modify the scoring regulations in order to accommodate “park ball.” According to the way I score park ball, if the runner breaks for second as the pitcher begins his or her advance towards home and the runner makes it all the way to second, it is considered a stolen base.

In my opinion, the runner must work hard for the theft.

Defensive Indifference… and why defenses should not be indifferent about them

My scoring rule article on stolen bases includes a brief description of the circumstance that is scored as defensive indifference, which may be found at the conclusion of the essay. In addition, if you read it, you’ll notice that I don’t particularly like the way this regulation is worded, as you can see below. When “a runner advances entirely as a result of the defensive team’s indifference to the runner’s advance,” the rule states that a stolen base is not awarded. After that, it provides some helpful guidance on how to determine whether or not the team was truly indifferent, such as this nugget of wisdom, which states that you should consider “the totality of circumstances, including the inning and score of the game, whether the defensive team had held the runner on base, whether the pitcher had made any pickoff attempts on that runner before the runner’s advance, whether the fielder ordinarily expected to cover the base to which the runner advanced mad, whether the fielder ordinari Okay, do you understand what I’m saying?

  1. I don’t know what to say either.
  2. Is it more necessary to steal bases later in the game than it is earlier in the game?
  3. Some of you may be startled by the response.
  4. What would constitute a sound strategic justification?
  5. If there is a runner on first and third base, you may not want to throw to second base, which would allow the runner to advance to third base.

Except for the fact that the rule specifically addresses such situation in a comment: “For example, when there are runners on first and third bases, the official scorer should generally credit a stolen base when the runner on first advances to second.” But the part of this regulation that really annoys me is that a team should almost never be indifferent about allowing a runner to steal a base in the first place.

When a runner advances one base, the victory probability of the team as well as the run expectation of the inning as a whole increase.

It’s hard for me to forget a particular Major League Baseball game where “defensive indifference” not only made all the difference in the outcome of the game, but also helped one of the teams qualify for the postseason and set up a walkoff victory that foreshadowed some much more spectacular performances in subsequent playoffs.

The team was the Boston Red Sox.

You can almost forgive Mike Hargrove for being in cruise control and allowing the not-so-speedy Varitek to take 2nd base uncontested when you’re down by three runs in that situation (4.9 percent, according to the table in The Book: Playing the Percentages in Baseball), so long as you’re not down by more than three runs.

Remember, this is the type of simple ground ball that would be turned into a double play if there was an outfielder on first base.

The following hitter took a walk, bringing the tying run to the plate, and you guessed it, the game was tied.

David Ortiz led off the bottom of the tenth inning with a walk-off home run, capping up a successful night for the Red Sox in Boston.

Because Baltimore was “indifferent” to a meaningless runner who was moving from first to second, all of this was made possible.

Any attempts to steal should be counted as stolen bases or as caught stealing, depending on the circumstances. Simply said, there is no need to know the thoughts of a player in order to make the perfect scoring option.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.